Forum Discussion

Bryan_90908's avatar
Bryan_90908
Icon for Nimbostratus rankNimbostratus
May 16, 2011

F5 vs Open Source?

Greetings group,

 

I’ve been tasked with comparing the use of open source load balancing software server solutions against commercially available off the shelf hardware. We are currently using F5 and have been happy with the products and honestly i'm not really sure why this has come about.

 

We use the load balancers currently for traditional load balancing, full proxy for http/ssl traffic, ssl termination and certificate management, ssl and http header manipulation, nat, high availability of the physical hardware and stateful failover of the tcp sessions. These units will be placed at the customer prem supporting our applications and services and we’ll need to support them accordingly.

 

Now my “knee jerk” reaction to this is that it’s a really bad idea. It is the heart and soul of our data center network. However, once I started to think about it I realized that I hadn’t had any real experience with this solution beyond tinkering with it at home and reading about it in years past.

 

 

Can anyone offer any operational insight and real world experiences with these solutions?

 

 

4 Replies

  • About a year and a half ago, the powers that be sent me on a similar mission as they looked at any licensing and other costs that they could reduce. One result of that larger effort is that someone sold the idea of going with mail hosted by a consumer focused company with a large advertising revenue stream.... But I digress.

     

     

    Possible, YES. However there is the management and failover which I found to be the most troubling. Admittedly I am not 'nix admin so I do not know of all the tricks that they may have to bring to the table, but a simple concept like an HA pair of servers hosting NGinX had the smart Linux guys I know scratching their heads when I ran scenarios by them. As is the case with most things 'nix, all the configs are via files, so a simple syntax error will halt the entire process. Syncing the config files is also something that will require creative thinking too. Once you build out a FOSS stack, and it will be a stack of different solutions to get all of the features, good luck keeping the Rube Goldbergian system glued together and not ever fouled by a misconfiguration. To pull it off you would need many people on your team to support the solution who are 'nix, application, and networking GURUs, otherwise a novice without a full understanding of the system could mistakenly bring the whole house of cards down. There was a Long debate that Lori M sparked with some FOSS folks not too long ago where you can read their declarations of "Yes we can!" but the details of their solution made my head hurt. Oh and forget admin partitions where u let app owners take nodes one and offline, that is now your job. Also forget everything that is done well with the custom ASICs(SSL Termination & Compression come to mind) inherent with the HW ADC solutions.

     

     

     

    An ADC solution built on FOSS is not a one stop shop and requires a high degree of expertise to make it all flow nicely. And with the huge chain of software needed, extensive unit testing would be needed before rolling sw updates to the various modules that would be needed to ensure no disruption of services. And at 2 AM when the solution crashes, which of the umpteen modules caused the crash, who can you get support from and get back online without loosing revenue? How tolerant will management be to wait for you to crawl twenty or so different forums for the modules involved and waiting on responses to posts to attempt to fix the issue?

     

     

     

    Regards,

     

     

     

    CarlB

     

  • To elaborate on Carl's point a bit, an ADC is one of the most critical components of a network and therefore must be supported. A good ADC lets you do absorb failures in other places inside your network but putting millions of dollars worth of applications and infrastructure behind something open source and free is a bit risky.
  • Hi Brian,

     

    There is an excellent article that was written by F5s Lori MacVittie.

     

     

    http://devcentral.f5.com/weblogs/macvittie/archive/2009/04/17/dear-slashdot-you-get-what-you-pay-for.aspx

     

     

    This topic generated interesting conversations in the community.

     

     

    However, ultimately it comes down to 2 important questions (minus the cost)

     

    1) How much features you need and not what you want.

     

    2) Can your existing support organization support it (Development, Deployment and Support).

     

     

    I hope this helps,

     

    Bhattman

     

     

     

  • This is my personal philosophy on architecture / ADN design, which I've put into practice in various capacities. At the risk of this sounding like marketing fluff, one of the main ideas is to put an emphasis on a select set of strategic points of control in your network, then leverage the hell out of them. For me, this stack included the following technologies:

     

     

    -- BigIP

     

    -- Solaris (for Oracle)

     

    -- NetApp

     

    -- SLES Linux

     

    -- The Apache/Tomcat stack

     

    -- Commodity x64 servers, horizontally scaled

     

     

    Obviously, there are tons of possible variations and valid arguments for/against this stack, but we found that using this simple stack we could address the vast majority of application delivery challenges that the business would toss our way. You can see the strategic points where we focused our capital investment: BigIP, NetApp, and Oracle.

     

     

    Why? We found that using these specific technologies allowed us to say yes far more than no to the business owners, my boss(es), our CTO, etc.

     

     

    With an open source solution in place at the BigIP layer, I can say with 100% certainty that I would have had to have made significant compromises to our application delivery environment, if not having to say "no" to a huge swath of use cases.

     

     

    To blatantly rip off Larry Wall's famous quote: BigIP makes easy things easy and difficult things possible. With an open source LB solution this doesn't hold, particularly at scale: e.g., ask an open source solution to handle 1 million concurrent connections, let alone 32 million, or to 65,000 SSL TPS with 2048-bit keys. There are several reasons for this, but suffice it to say that there are (to me, at least) certain workloads and tasks that require purpose-built, high performance, kick-arse stuff. More and more, people are essentially asking for middleware on the wire, a task that BigIP is uniquely suited for.

     

     

    Now, FWIW, I love open source and I've bet my career on it in many respects. But for me it's more about the right tool for the right job. F5 has a ton of *really* smart folks dedicated to making their technology do incredible things. It's a good idea to leverage that domain expertise for this type of job.

     

     

    Just my $.02 on this interesting thread!

     

     

    -- Matt

     

"}},"componentScriptGroups({\"componentId\":\"custom.widget.Beta_MetaNav\"})":{"__typename":"ComponentScriptGroups","scriptGroups":{"__typename":"ComponentScriptGroupsDefinition","afterInteractive":{"__typename":"PageScriptGroupDefinition","group":"AFTER_INTERACTIVE","scriptIds":[]},"lazyOnLoad":{"__typename":"PageScriptGroupDefinition","group":"LAZY_ON_LOAD","scriptIds":[]}},"componentScripts":[]},"component({\"componentId\":\"custom.widget.Community_Quicklinks\"})":{"__typename":"Component","render({\"context\":{\"component\":{\"entities\":[],\"props\":{}},\"page\":{\"entities\":[\"message:202123\"],\"name\":\"ForumMessagePage\",\"props\":{},\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/discussions/technicalforum/f5-vs-open-source/202123\"}}})":{"__typename":"ComponentRenderResult","html":"
Under Attack? F5 Will Help You.
Contacting F5 Support?

 
DevCentral Quicklinks

* Getting Started on DevCentral
* Community Guidelines
* Community Terms of Use / EULA
* Community Ranking Explained
* Community Resources
* Contact the DevCentral Team
* Update MFA on account.f5.com

Discover DevCentral Connects

* Podcasts
* Social Channels
* Video Streaming

GitHub Awesome-F5
"}},"componentScriptGroups({\"componentId\":\"custom.widget.Community_Quicklinks\"})":{"__typename":"ComponentScriptGroups","scriptGroups":{"__typename":"ComponentScriptGroupsDefinition","afterInteractive":{"__typename":"PageScriptGroupDefinition","group":"AFTER_INTERACTIVE","scriptIds":[]},"lazyOnLoad":{"__typename":"PageScriptGroupDefinition","group":"LAZY_ON_LOAD","scriptIds":[]}},"componentScripts":[]},"component({\"componentId\":\"custom.widget.Beta_Footer\"})":{"__typename":"Component","render({\"context\":{\"component\":{\"entities\":[],\"props\":{}},\"page\":{\"entities\":[\"message:202123\"],\"name\":\"ForumMessagePage\",\"props\":{},\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/discussions/technicalforum/f5-vs-open-source/202123\"}}})":{"__typename":"ComponentRenderResult","html":"
 
 
 
 
 

\"F5 ©2024 F5, Inc. All rights reserved.
Trademarks Policies Privacy California Privacy Do Not Sell My Personal Information
"}},"componentScriptGroups({\"componentId\":\"custom.widget.Beta_Footer\"})":{"__typename":"ComponentScriptGroups","scriptGroups":{"__typename":"ComponentScriptGroupsDefinition","afterInteractive":{"__typename":"PageScriptGroupDefinition","group":"AFTER_INTERACTIVE","scriptIds":[]},"lazyOnLoad":{"__typename":"PageScriptGroupDefinition","group":"LAZY_ON_LOAD","scriptIds":[]}},"componentScripts":[]},"component({\"componentId\":\"custom.widget.Tag_Manager_Helper\"})":{"__typename":"Component","render({\"context\":{\"component\":{\"entities\":[],\"props\":{}},\"page\":{\"entities\":[\"message:202123\"],\"name\":\"ForumMessagePage\",\"props\":{},\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/discussions/technicalforum/f5-vs-open-source/202123\"}}})":{"__typename":"ComponentRenderResult","html":" "}},"componentScriptGroups({\"componentId\":\"custom.widget.Tag_Manager_Helper\"})":{"__typename":"ComponentScriptGroups","scriptGroups":{"__typename":"ComponentScriptGroupsDefinition","afterInteractive":{"__typename":"PageScriptGroupDefinition","group":"AFTER_INTERACTIVE","scriptIds":[]},"lazyOnLoad":{"__typename":"PageScriptGroupDefinition","group":"LAZY_ON_LOAD","scriptIds":[]}},"componentScripts":[]},"component({\"componentId\":\"custom.widget.Consent_Blackbar\"})":{"__typename":"Component","render({\"context\":{\"component\":{\"entities\":[],\"props\":{}},\"page\":{\"entities\":[\"message:202123\"],\"name\":\"ForumMessagePage\",\"props\":{},\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/discussions/technicalforum/f5-vs-open-source/202123\"}}})":{"__typename":"ComponentRenderResult","html":"
"}},"componentScriptGroups({\"componentId\":\"custom.widget.Consent_Blackbar\"})":{"__typename":"ComponentScriptGroups","scriptGroups":{"__typename":"ComponentScriptGroupsDefinition","afterInteractive":{"__typename":"PageScriptGroupDefinition","group":"AFTER_INTERACTIVE","scriptIds":[]},"lazyOnLoad":{"__typename":"PageScriptGroupDefinition","group":"LAZY_ON_LOAD","scriptIds":[]}},"componentScripts":[]},"featuredContentWidget({\"coreNodeId\":\"board:TechnicalForum\",\"instanceId\":\"featuredWidgets.widget.featuredContentWidget-1705956211049\",\"quiltId\":\"ForumMessagePage\"})":{"__typename":"FeaturedContentWidget","messages({\"first\":3})":{"__typename":"MessageConnection","totalCount":2,"edges":[{"__typename":"MessageEdge","node":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:340911"}},{"__typename":"MessageEdge","node":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:340701"}}],"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null}},"lastModified":1745603408966,"lastModifiedUser":{"__ref":"User:user:7"}},"cachedText({\"lastModified\":\"1745595729370\",\"locale\":\"en-US\",\"namespaces\":[\"components/community/NavbarDropdownToggle\"]})":[{"__ref":"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/community/NavbarDropdownToggle-1745595729370"}],"cachedText({\"lastModified\":\"1745595729370\",\"locale\":\"en-US\",\"namespaces\":[\"shared/client/components/users/UserAvatar\"]})":[{"__ref":"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/users/UserAvatar-1745595729370"}],"cachedText({\"lastModified\":\"1745595729370\",\"locale\":\"en-US\",\"namespaces\":[\"shared/client/components/ranks/UserRankLabel\"]})":[{"__ref":"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/ranks/UserRankLabel-1745595729370"}],"cachedText({\"lastModified\":\"1745595729370\",\"locale\":\"en-US\",\"namespaces\":[\"components/tags/TagView/TagViewChip\"]})":[{"__ref":"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/tags/TagView/TagViewChip-1745595729370"}],"cachedText({\"lastModified\":\"1745595729370\",\"locale\":\"en-US\",\"namespaces\":[\"components/messages/MessageListMenu\"]})":[{"__ref":"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageListMenu-1745595729370"}],"cachedText({\"lastModified\":\"1745595729370\",\"locale\":\"en-US\",\"namespaces\":[\"components/messages/AcceptedSolutionButton\"]})":[{"__ref":"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/AcceptedSolutionButton-1745595729370"}],"cachedText({\"lastModified\":\"1745595729370\",\"locale\":\"en-US\",\"namespaces\":[\"components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewCard\"]})":[{"__ref":"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewCard-1745595729370"}],"cachedText({\"lastModified\":\"1745595729370\",\"locale\":\"en-US\",\"namespaces\":[\"components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewInline\"]})":[{"__ref":"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewInline-1745595729370"}],"cachedText({\"lastModified\":\"1745595729370\",\"locale\":\"en-US\",\"namespaces\":[\"shared/client/components/common/Pager/PagerLoadMore\"]})":[{"__ref":"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/common/Pager/PagerLoadMore-1745595729370"}],"cachedText({\"lastModified\":\"1745595729370\",\"locale\":\"en-US\",\"namespaces\":[\"components/customComponent/CustomComponent\"]})":[{"__ref":"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/customComponent/CustomComponent-1745595729370"}],"message({\"id\":\"message:202124\"})":{"__ref":"ForumReplyMessage:message:202124"},"message({\"id\":\"message:202125\"})":{"__ref":"ForumReplyMessage:message:202125"},"message({\"id\":\"message:202126\"})":{"__ref":"ForumReplyMessage:message:202126"},"message({\"id\":\"message:202127\"})":{"__ref":"ForumReplyMessage:message:202127"},"message({\"id\":\"message:340911\"})":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:340911"},"message({\"id\":\"message:340701\"})":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:340701"},"cachedText({\"lastModified\":\"1745595729370\",\"locale\":\"en-US\",\"namespaces\":[\"shared/client/components/nodes/NodeIcon\"]})":[{"__ref":"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/nodes/NodeIcon-1745595729370"}]},"Theme:customTheme1":{"__typename":"Theme","id":"customTheme1"},"User:user:-1":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:-1","uid":-1,"login":"Former Member","email":"","avatar":null,"rank":null,"kudosWeight":1,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":"ANONYMOUS","registrationTime":null,"confirmEmailStatus":false,"registrationAccessLevel":"VIEW","ssoRegistrationFields":[]},"ssoId":null,"profileSettings":{"__typename":"ProfileSettings","dateDisplayStyle":{"__typename":"InheritableStringSettingWithPossibleValues","key":"layout.friendly_dates_enabled","value":"false","localValue":"true","possibleValues":["true","false"]},"dateDisplayFormat":{"__typename":"InheritableStringSetting","key":"layout.format_pattern_date","value":"dd-MMM-yyyy","localValue":"MM-dd-yyyy"},"language":{"__typename":"InheritableStringSettingWithPossibleValues","key":"profile.language","value":"en-US","localValue":null,"possibleValues":["en-US","es-ES"]},"repliesSortOrder":{"__typename":"InheritableStringSettingWithPossibleValues","key":"config.user_replies_sort_order","value":"DEFAULT","localValue":"DEFAULT","possibleValues":["DEFAULT","LIKES","PUBLISH_TIME","REVERSE_PUBLISH_TIME"]}},"deleted":false},"CachedAsset:pages-1745595724052":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"pages-1745595724052","value":[{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"BlogViewAllPostsPage","type":"BLOG","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/blog/:boardId/all-posts/(/:after|/:before)?","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"CasePortalPage","type":"CASE_PORTAL","urlPath":"/caseportal","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"CreateGroupHubPage","type":"GROUP_HUB","urlPath":"/groups/create","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"CaseViewPage","type":"CASE_DETAILS","urlPath":"/case/:caseId/:caseNumber","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"InboxPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/inbox","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"HelpFAQPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/help","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"IdeaMessagePage","type":"IDEA_POST","urlPath":"/idea/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"IdeaViewAllIdeasPage","type":"IDEA","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/ideas/:boardId/all-ideas/(/:after|/:before)?","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"LoginPage","type":"USER","urlPath":"/signin","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"BlogPostPage","type":"BLOG","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/blogs/:boardId/create","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1739501733000,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"Test","type":"CUSTOM","urlPath":"/custom-test-2","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ThemeEditorPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/designer/themes","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"TkbViewAllArticlesPage","type":"TKB","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/kb/:boardId/all-articles/(/:after|/:before)?","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"OccasionEditPage","type":"EVENT","urlPath":"/event/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId/edit","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"OAuthAuthorizationAllowPage","type":"USER","urlPath":"/auth/authorize/allow","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"PageEditorPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/designer/pages","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"PostPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/:boardId/create","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ForumBoardPage","type":"FORUM","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/discussions/:boardId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"TkbBoardPage","type":"TKB","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/kb/:boardId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"EventPostPage","type":"EVENT","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/events/:boardId/create","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"UserBadgesPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/users/:login/:userId/badges","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"GroupHubMembershipAction","type":"GROUP_HUB","urlPath":"/membership/join/:nodeId/:membershipType","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"MaintenancePage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/maintenance","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"IdeaReplyPage","type":"IDEA_REPLY","urlPath":"/idea/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId/comments/:replyId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"UserSettingsPage","type":"USER","urlPath":"/mysettings/:userSettingsTab","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"GroupHubsPage","type":"GROUP_HUB","urlPath":"/groups","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ForumPostPage","type":"FORUM","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/discussions/:boardId/create","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"OccasionRsvpActionPage","type":"OCCASION","urlPath":"/event/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId/rsvp/:responseType","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"VerifyUserEmailPage","type":"USER","urlPath":"/verifyemail/:userId/:verifyEmailToken","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"AllOccasionsPage","type":"OCCASION","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/events/:boardId/all-events/(/:after|/:before)?","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"EventBoardPage","type":"EVENT","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/events/:boardId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"TkbReplyPage","type":"TKB_REPLY","urlPath":"/kb/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId/comments/:replyId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"IdeaBoardPage","type":"IDEA","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/ideas/:boardId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"CommunityGuideLinesPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/communityguidelines","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"CaseCreatePage","type":"SALESFORCE_CASE_CREATION","urlPath":"/caseportal/create","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"TkbEditPage","type":"TKB","urlPath":"/kb/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId/edit","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ForgotPasswordPage","type":"USER","urlPath":"/forgotpassword","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"IdeaEditPage","type":"IDEA","urlPath":"/idea/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId/edit","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"TagPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/tag/:tagName","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"BlogBoardPage","type":"BLOG","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/blog/:boardId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"OccasionMessagePage","type":"OCCASION_TOPIC","urlPath":"/event/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ManageContentPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/managecontent","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ClosedMembershipNodeNonMembersPage","type":"GROUP_HUB","urlPath":"/closedgroup/:groupHubId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"CommunityPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ForumMessagePage","type":"FORUM_TOPIC","urlPath":"/discussions/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"IdeaPostPage","type":"IDEA","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/ideas/:boardId/create","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"BlogMessagePage","type":"BLOG_ARTICLE","urlPath":"/blog/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"RegistrationPage","type":"USER","urlPath":"/register","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"EditGroupHubPage","type":"GROUP_HUB","urlPath":"/group/:groupHubId/edit","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ForumEditPage","type":"FORUM","urlPath":"/discussions/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId/edit","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ResetPasswordPage","type":"USER","urlPath":"/resetpassword/:userId/:resetPasswordToken","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"TkbMessagePage","type":"TKB_ARTICLE","urlPath":"/kb/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"BlogEditPage","type":"BLOG","urlPath":"/blog/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId/edit","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ManageUsersPage","type":"USER","urlPath":"/users/manage/:tab?/:manageUsersTab?","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ForumReplyPage","type":"FORUM_REPLY","urlPath":"/discussions/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId/replies/:replyId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"PrivacyPolicyPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/privacypolicy","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"NotificationPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/notifications","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"UserPage","type":"USER","urlPath":"/users/:login/:userId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"HealthCheckPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/health","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"OccasionReplyPage","type":"OCCASION_REPLY","urlPath":"/event/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId/comments/:replyId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ManageMembersPage","type":"GROUP_HUB","urlPath":"/group/:groupHubId/manage/:tab?","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"SearchResultsPage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/search","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"BlogReplyPage","type":"BLOG_REPLY","urlPath":"/blog/:boardId/:messageSubject/:messageId/replies/:replyId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"GroupHubPage","type":"GROUP_HUB","urlPath":"/group/:groupHubId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"TermsOfServicePage","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/termsofservice","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"CategoryPage","type":"CATEGORY","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"ForumViewAllTopicsPage","type":"FORUM","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/discussions/:boardId/all-topics/(/:after|/:before)?","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"TkbPostPage","type":"TKB","urlPath":"/category/:categoryId/kbs/:boardId/create","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"GroupHubPostPage","type":"GROUP_HUB","urlPath":"/group/:groupHubId/:boardId/create","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"},{"lastUpdatedTime":1745595724052,"localOverride":null,"page":{"id":"HowDoI","type":"COMMUNITY","urlPath":"/c/how-do-i","__typename":"PageDescriptor"},"__typename":"PageResource"}],"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/context/AppContext/AppContextProvider-0":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/context/AppContext/AppContextProvider-0","value":{"noCommunity":"Cannot find community","noUser":"Cannot find current user","noNode":"Cannot find node with id {nodeId}","noMessage":"Cannot find message with id {messageId}","userBanned":"We're sorry, but you have been banned from using this site.","userBannedReason":"You have been banned for the following reason: {reason}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/common/Loading/LoadingDot-0":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/common/Loading/LoadingDot-0","value":{"title":"Loading..."},"localOverride":false},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstNDEtSzFzVEth\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstNDEtSzFzVEth","height":0,"width":0,"mimeType":"image/svg+xml"},"Rank:rank:41":{"__typename":"Rank","id":"rank:41","position":18,"name":"Nimbostratus","color":"CCCCCC","icon":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstNDEtSzFzVEth\"}"},"rankStyle":"FILLED"},"User:user:169225":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:169225","uid":169225,"login":"Bryan_90908","deleted":false,"avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/m_assets/avatars/default/avatar-11.svg?time=0"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:41"},"email":"","messagesCount":3,"biography":null,"topicsCount":3,"kudosReceivedCount":0,"kudosGivenCount":0,"kudosWeight":1,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2008-05-29T01:00:00.000-07:00","confirmEmailStatus":null},"followersCount":null,"solutionsCount":0},"Category:category:Forums":{"__typename":"Category","id":"category:Forums","entityType":"CATEGORY","displayId":"Forums","nodeType":"category","depth":1,"title":"Forums","shortTitle":"Forums","parent":{"__ref":"Category:category:top"},"categoryPolicies":{"__typename":"CategoryPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}}},"Category:category:top":{"__typename":"Category","id":"category:top","entityType":"CATEGORY","displayId":"top","nodeType":"category","depth":0,"title":"Top","shortTitle":"Top"},"Forum:board:TechnicalForum":{"__typename":"Forum","id":"board:TechnicalForum","entityType":"FORUM","displayId":"TechnicalForum","nodeType":"board","depth":2,"conversationStyle":"FORUM","repliesProperties":{"__typename":"RepliesProperties","sortOrder":"PUBLISH_TIME","repliesFormat":"threaded"},"tagProperties":{"__typename":"TagNodeProperties","tagsEnabled":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"requireTags":true,"tagType":"FREEFORM_AND_PRESET","description":"Ask questions.\r\nDiscover Answers.","title":"Technical Forum","shortTitle":"Technical Forum","parent":{"__ref":"Category:category:Forums"},"ancestors":{"__typename":"CoreNodeConnection","edges":[{"__typename":"CoreNodeEdge","node":{"__ref":"Community:community:zihoc95639"}},{"__typename":"CoreNodeEdge","node":{"__ref":"Category:category:Forums"}}]},"userContext":{"__typename":"NodeUserContext","canAddAttachments":false,"canUpdateNode":false,"canPostMessages":false,"isSubscribed":false},"theme":{"__ref":"Theme:customTheme1"},"boardPolicies":{"__typename":"BoardPolicies","canViewSpamDashBoard":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":{"__typename":"FailureReason","message":"error.lithium.policies.feature.moderation_spam.action.access_spam_quarantine.allowed.accessDenied","key":"error.lithium.policies.feature.moderation_spam.action.access_spam_quarantine.allowed.accessDenied","args":[]}},"canArchiveMessage":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":{"__typename":"FailureReason","message":"error.lithium.policies.content_archivals.enable_content_archival_settings.accessDenied","key":"error.lithium.policies.content_archivals.enable_content_archival_settings.accessDenied","args":[]}},"canPublishArticleOnCreate":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":{"__typename":"FailureReason","message":"error.lithium.policies.forums.policy_can_publish_on_create_workflow_action.accessDenied","key":"error.lithium.policies.forums.policy_can_publish_on_create_workflow_action.accessDenied","args":[]}},"canManageFeaturedWidget":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":{"__typename":"FailureReason","message":"error.lithium.policies.feature.featured_widgets.action.admin_featured_widget.allowed.accessDenied","key":"error.lithium.policies.feature.featured_widgets.action.admin_featured_widget.allowed.accessDenied","args":[]}},"canUpdateFeaturedWidget":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":{"__typename":"FailureReason","message":"error.lithium.policies.feature.featured_widgets.action.update_featured_widget.allowed.accessDenied","key":"error.lithium.policies.feature.featured_widgets.action.update_featured_widget.allowed.accessDenied","args":[]}},"canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"forumPolicies":{"__typename":"ForumPolicies","canManageFeaturedWidget":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":{"__typename":"FailureReason","message":"error.lithium.policies.feature.featured_widgets.action.admin_featured_widget.allowed.accessDenied","key":"error.lithium.policies.feature.featured_widgets.action.admin_featured_widget.allowed.accessDenied","args":[]}},"canUpdateFeaturedWidget":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":{"__typename":"FailureReason","message":"error.lithium.policies.feature.featured_widgets.action.update_featured_widget.allowed.accessDenied","key":"error.lithium.policies.feature.featured_widgets.action.update_featured_widget.allowed.accessDenied","args":[]}},"canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"eventPath":"category:Forums/community:zihoc95639board:TechnicalForum/","avatar":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi0zMS0yaUY5MjM3RDI3NzVEQzI1M0U\"}"}},"ForumTopicMessage:message:202123":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","uid":202123,"subject":"F5 vs Open Source?","id":"message:202123","revisionNum":1,"repliesCount":4,"author":{"__ref":"User:user:169225"},"depth":0,"hasGivenKudo":false,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:202123"},"readOnly":false,"editFrozen":false,"moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:202123"},"body":"Greetings group,

\n

 

I’ve been tasked with comparing the use of open source load\nbalancing software server solutions against commercially available off the shelf hardware. We are currently using F5 and have been happy with the products and honestly i'm not really sure why this has come about.

 

We use the load balancers currently for traditional load balancing, full\nproxy for http/ssl traffic, ssl termination and certificate management, ssl and\nhttp header manipulation, nat, high availability of the physical hardware and\nstateful failover of the tcp sessions. \nThese units will be placed at the customer prem supporting our\napplications and services and we’ll need to support them accordingly.

 

Now my “knee jerk” reaction to this is that it’s a really\nbad idea. It is the heart and soul of\nour data center network. \nHowever, once I started to think about it I realized that I hadn’t had\nany real experience with this solution beyond tinkering with it at home and\nreading about it in years past.

 

 

Can anyone offer any operational insight and real world\nexperiences with these solutions?

 

 

","body@stringLength":"1260","rawBody":"Greetings group,

\n

 

I’ve been tasked with comparing the use of open source load\nbalancing software server solutions against commercially available off the shelf hardware. We are currently using F5 and have been happy with the products and honestly i'm not really sure why this has come about.

 

We use the load balancers currently for traditional load balancing, full\nproxy for http/ssl traffic, ssl termination and certificate management, ssl and\nhttp header manipulation, nat, high availability of the physical hardware and\nstateful failover of the tcp sessions. \nThese units will be placed at the customer prem supporting our\napplications and services and we’ll need to support them accordingly.

 

Now my “knee jerk” reaction to this is that it’s a really\nbad idea. It is the heart and soul of\nour data center network. \nHowever, once I started to think about it I realized that I hadn’t had\nany real experience with this solution beyond tinkering with it at home and\nreading about it in years past.

 

 

Can anyone offer any operational insight and real world\nexperiences with these solutions?

 

 

","kudosSumWeight":0,"postTime":"2011-05-16T16:05:32.000-07:00","images":{"__typename":"AssociatedImageConnection","edges":[],"totalCount":0,"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"attachments":{"__typename":"AttachmentConnection","pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null},"edges":[]},"tags":{"__typename":"TagConnection","pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null},"edges":[{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8b3wxMHxfTlZffDE","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:config","text":"config","time":"2022-01-24T02:29:45.173-08:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}},{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8b3wxMHxfTlZffDI","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:design","text":"design","time":"2022-01-24T02:29:45.172-08:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}}]},"timeToRead":1,"currentRevision":{"__ref":"Revision:revision:202123_1"},"latestVersion":null,"metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":1101},"visibilityScope":"PUBLIC","canonicalUrl":null,"seoTitle":null,"seoDescription":null,"isEscalated":null,"placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"messagePolicies":{"__typename":"MessagePolicies","canModerateSpamMessage":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":{"__typename":"FailureReason","message":"error.lithium.policies.feature.moderation_spam.action.moderate_entity.allowed.accessDenied","key":"error.lithium.policies.feature.moderation_spam.action.moderate_entity.allowed.accessDenied","args":[]}}},"archivalData":null,"searchSnippet":"Greetings group, \n   I’ve been tasked with comparing the use of open source load\nbalancing software server solutions against commercially available off the shelf hardware. We are currently us...","replies":{"__typename":"MessageConnection","edges":[{"__typename":"MessageEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8aXwxMHwzOToxfGludCwyMDIxMjQsMjAyMTI0","node":{"__ref":"ForumReplyMessage:message:202124"}},{"__typename":"MessageEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8aXwxMHwzOToxfGludCwyMDIxMjQsMjAyMTI1","node":{"__ref":"ForumReplyMessage:message:202125"}},{"__typename":"MessageEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8aXwxMHwzOToxfGludCwyMDIxMjQsMjAyMTI2","node":{"__ref":"ForumReplyMessage:message:202126"}},{"__typename":"MessageEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8aXwxMHwzOToxfGludCwyMDIxMjQsMjAyMTI3","node":{"__ref":"ForumReplyMessage:message:202127"}}],"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"customFields":[]},"Conversation:conversation:202123":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:202123","solved":false,"topic":{"__ref":"ForumTopicMessage:message:202123"},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2011-06-21T21:26:55.000-07:00","lastPostTime":"2011-06-21T21:26:55.000-07:00","unreadReplyCount":4,"isSubscribed":false},"ModerationData:moderation_data:202123":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:202123","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null,"isReportedAbuse":false,"rejectUser":null,"rejectTime":null,"rejectActorType":null},"Revision:revision:202123_1":{"__typename":"Revision","id":"revision:202123_1","lastEditTime":"2011-05-16T16:05:32.000-07:00"},"CachedAsset:theme:customTheme1-1745595709926":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"theme:customTheme1-1745595709926","value":{"id":"customTheme1","animation":{"fast":"150ms","normal":"250ms","slow":"500ms","slowest":"750ms","function":"cubic-bezier(0.07, 0.91, 0.51, 1)","__typename":"AnimationThemeSettings"},"avatar":{"borderRadius":"50%","collections":["custom"],"__typename":"AvatarThemeSettings"},"basics":{"browserIcon":{"imageAssetName":"JimmyPackets-512-1702592938213.png","imageLastModified":"1702592945815","__typename":"ThemeAsset"},"customerLogo":{"imageAssetName":"f5_logo_fix-1704824537976.svg","imageLastModified":"1704824540697","__typename":"ThemeAsset"},"maximumWidthOfPageContent":"1600px","oneColumnNarrowWidth":"800px","gridGutterWidthMd":"30px","gridGutterWidthXs":"10px","pageWidthStyle":"WIDTH_OF_PAGE_CONTENT","__typename":"BasicsThemeSettings"},"buttons":{"borderRadiusSm":"5px","borderRadius":"5px","borderRadiusLg":"5px","paddingY":"5px","paddingYLg":"7px","paddingYHero":"var(--lia-bs-btn-padding-y-lg)","paddingX":"12px","paddingXLg":"14px","paddingXHero":"42px","fontStyle":"NORMAL","fontWeight":"400","textTransform":"NONE","disabledOpacity":0.5,"primaryTextColor":"var(--lia-bs-white)","primaryTextHoverColor":"var(--lia-bs-white)","primaryTextActiveColor":"var(--lia-bs-white)","primaryBgColor":"var(--lia-bs-primary)","primaryBgHoverColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-primary-h), var(--lia-bs-primary-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-primary-l) * 0.85))","primaryBgActiveColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-primary-h), var(--lia-bs-primary-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-primary-l) * 0.7))","primaryBorder":"1px solid transparent","primaryBorderHover":"1px solid transparent","primaryBorderActive":"1px solid transparent","primaryBorderFocus":"1px solid var(--lia-bs-white)","primaryBoxShadowFocus":"0 0 0 1px var(--lia-bs-primary), 0 0 0 4px hsla(var(--lia-bs-primary-h), var(--lia-bs-primary-s), var(--lia-bs-primary-l), 0.2)","secondaryTextColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-900)","secondaryTextHoverColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-l) * 0.95))","secondaryTextActiveColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-l) * 0.9))","secondaryBgColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-400)","secondaryBgHoverColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-gray-400-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-400-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-gray-400-l) * 0.96))","secondaryBgActiveColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-gray-400-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-400-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-gray-400-l) * 0.92))","secondaryBorder":"1px solid transparent","secondaryBorderHover":"1px solid transparent","secondaryBorderActive":"1px solid transparent","secondaryBorderFocus":"1px solid transparent","secondaryBoxShadowFocus":"0 0 0 1px var(--lia-bs-primary), 0 0 0 4px hsla(var(--lia-bs-primary-h), var(--lia-bs-primary-s), var(--lia-bs-primary-l), 0.2)","tertiaryTextColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-900)","tertiaryTextHoverColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-l) * 0.95))","tertiaryTextActiveColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-l) * 0.9))","tertiaryBgColor":"transparent","tertiaryBgHoverColor":"transparent","tertiaryBgActiveColor":"hsla(var(--lia-bs-black-h), var(--lia-bs-black-s), var(--lia-bs-black-l), 0.04)","tertiaryBorder":"1px solid transparent","tertiaryBorderHover":"1px solid hsla(var(--lia-bs-black-h), var(--lia-bs-black-s), var(--lia-bs-black-l), 0.08)","tertiaryBorderActive":"1px solid transparent","tertiaryBorderFocus":"1px solid transparent","tertiaryBoxShadowFocus":"0 0 0 1px var(--lia-bs-primary), 0 0 0 4px hsla(var(--lia-bs-primary-h), var(--lia-bs-primary-s), var(--lia-bs-primary-l), 0.2)","destructiveTextColor":"var(--lia-bs-danger)","destructiveTextHoverColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-danger-h), var(--lia-bs-danger-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-danger-l) * 0.95))","destructiveTextActiveColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-danger-h), var(--lia-bs-danger-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-danger-l) * 0.9))","destructiveBgColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-300)","destructiveBgHoverColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-gray-300-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-300-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-gray-300-l) * 0.96))","destructiveBgActiveColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-gray-300-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-300-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-gray-300-l) * 0.92))","destructiveBorder":"1px solid transparent","destructiveBorderHover":"1px solid transparent","destructiveBorderActive":"1px solid transparent","destructiveBorderFocus":"1px solid transparent","destructiveBoxShadowFocus":"0 0 0 1px var(--lia-bs-primary), 0 0 0 4px hsla(var(--lia-bs-primary-h), var(--lia-bs-primary-s), var(--lia-bs-primary-l), 0.2)","__typename":"ButtonsThemeSettings"},"border":{"color":"hsla(var(--lia-bs-black-h), var(--lia-bs-black-s), var(--lia-bs-black-l), 0.08)","mainContent":"NONE","sideContent":"NONE","radiusSm":"3px","radius":"5px","radiusLg":"9px","radius50":"100vw","__typename":"BorderThemeSettings"},"boxShadow":{"xs":"0 0 0 1px hsla(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-s), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-l), 0.08), 0 3px 0 -1px hsla(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-s), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-l), 0.08)","sm":"0 2px 4px hsla(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-s), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-l), 0.06)","md":"0 5px 15px hsla(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-s), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-l), 0.15)","lg":"0 10px 30px hsla(var(--lia-bs-gray-900-h), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-s), var(--lia-bs-gray-900-l), 0.15)","__typename":"BoxShadowThemeSettings"},"cards":{"bgColor":"var(--lia-panel-bg-color)","borderRadius":"var(--lia-panel-border-radius)","boxShadow":"var(--lia-box-shadow-xs)","__typename":"CardsThemeSettings"},"chip":{"maxWidth":"300px","height":"30px","__typename":"ChipThemeSettings"},"coreTypes":{"defaultMessageLinkColor":"var(--lia-bs-primary)","defaultMessageLinkDecoration":"none","defaultMessageLinkFontStyle":"NORMAL","defaultMessageLinkFontWeight":"400","defaultMessageFontStyle":"NORMAL","defaultMessageFontWeight":"400","defaultMessageFontFamily":"var(--lia-bs-font-family-base)","forumColor":"#0C5C8D","forumFontFamily":"var(--lia-bs-font-family-base)","forumFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-font-weight)","forumLineHeight":"var(--lia-bs-line-height-base)","forumFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-font-style)","forumMessageLinkColor":"var(--lia-default-message-link-color)","forumMessageLinkDecoration":"var(--lia-default-message-link-decoration)","forumMessageLinkFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-style)","forumMessageLinkFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-weight)","forumSolvedColor":"#62C026","blogColor":"#730015","blogFontFamily":"var(--lia-bs-font-family-base)","blogFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-font-weight)","blogLineHeight":"1.75","blogFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-font-style)","blogMessageLinkColor":"var(--lia-default-message-link-color)","blogMessageLinkDecoration":"var(--lia-default-message-link-decoration)","blogMessageLinkFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-style)","blogMessageLinkFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-weight)","tkbColor":"#C20025","tkbFontFamily":"var(--lia-bs-font-family-base)","tkbFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-font-weight)","tkbLineHeight":"1.75","tkbFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-font-style)","tkbMessageLinkColor":"var(--lia-default-message-link-color)","tkbMessageLinkDecoration":"var(--lia-default-message-link-decoration)","tkbMessageLinkFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-style)","tkbMessageLinkFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-weight)","qandaColor":"#4099E2","qandaFontFamily":"var(--lia-bs-font-family-base)","qandaFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-font-weight)","qandaLineHeight":"var(--lia-bs-line-height-base)","qandaFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-style)","qandaMessageLinkColor":"var(--lia-default-message-link-color)","qandaMessageLinkDecoration":"var(--lia-default-message-link-decoration)","qandaMessageLinkFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-style)","qandaMessageLinkFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-weight)","qandaSolvedColor":"#3FA023","ideaColor":"#F3704B","ideaFontFamily":"var(--lia-bs-font-family-base)","ideaFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-font-weight)","ideaLineHeight":"var(--lia-bs-line-height-base)","ideaFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-font-style)","ideaMessageLinkColor":"var(--lia-default-message-link-color)","ideaMessageLinkDecoration":"var(--lia-default-message-link-decoration)","ideaMessageLinkFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-style)","ideaMessageLinkFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-weight)","contestColor":"#FCC845","contestFontFamily":"var(--lia-bs-font-family-base)","contestFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-font-weight)","contestLineHeight":"var(--lia-bs-line-height-base)","contestFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-style)","contestMessageLinkColor":"var(--lia-default-message-link-color)","contestMessageLinkDecoration":"var(--lia-default-message-link-decoration)","contestMessageLinkFontStyle":"ITALIC","contestMessageLinkFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-weight)","occasionColor":"#EE4B5B","occasionFontFamily":"var(--lia-bs-font-family-base)","occasionFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-font-weight)","occasionLineHeight":"var(--lia-bs-line-height-base)","occasionFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-font-style)","occasionMessageLinkColor":"var(--lia-default-message-link-color)","occasionMessageLinkDecoration":"var(--lia-default-message-link-decoration)","occasionMessageLinkFontStyle":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-style)","occasionMessageLinkFontWeight":"var(--lia-default-message-link-font-weight)","grouphubColor":"#491B62","categoryColor":"#949494","communityColor":"#FFFFFF","productColor":"#949494","__typename":"CoreTypesThemeSettings"},"colors":{"black":"#000000","white":"#FFFFFF","gray100":"#F7F7F7","gray200":"#F7F7F7","gray300":"#E8E8E8","gray400":"#D9D9D9","gray500":"#CCCCCC","gray600":"#949494","gray700":"#707070","gray800":"#545454","gray900":"#333333","dark":"#545454","light":"#F7F7F7","primary":"#0C5C8D","secondary":"#333333","bodyText":"#222222","bodyBg":"#F5F5F5","info":"#1D9CD3","success":"#62C026","warning":"#FFD651","danger":"#C20025","alertSystem":"#FF6600","textMuted":"#707070","highlight":"#FFFCAD","outline":"var(--lia-bs-primary)","custom":["#C20025","#081B85","#009639","#B3C6D7","#7CC0EB","#F29A36"],"__typename":"ColorsThemeSettings"},"divider":{"size":"3px","marginLeft":"4px","marginRight":"4px","borderRadius":"50%","bgColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-600)","bgColorActive":"var(--lia-bs-gray-600)","__typename":"DividerThemeSettings"},"dropdown":{"fontSize":"var(--lia-bs-font-size-sm)","borderColor":"var(--lia-bs-border-color)","borderRadius":"var(--lia-bs-border-radius-sm)","dividerBg":"var(--lia-bs-gray-300)","itemPaddingY":"5px","itemPaddingX":"20px","headerColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-700)","__typename":"DropdownThemeSettings"},"email":{"link":{"color":"#0069D4","hoverColor":"#0061c2","decoration":"none","hoverDecoration":"underline","__typename":"EmailLinkSettings"},"border":{"color":"#e4e4e4","__typename":"EmailBorderSettings"},"buttons":{"borderRadiusLg":"5px","paddingXLg":"16px","paddingYLg":"7px","fontWeight":"700","primaryTextColor":"#ffffff","primaryTextHoverColor":"#ffffff","primaryBgColor":"#0069D4","primaryBgHoverColor":"#005cb8","primaryBorder":"1px solid transparent","primaryBorderHover":"1px solid transparent","__typename":"EmailButtonsSettings"},"panel":{"borderRadius":"5px","borderColor":"#e4e4e4","__typename":"EmailPanelSettings"},"__typename":"EmailThemeSettings"},"emoji":{"skinToneDefault":"#ffcd43","skinToneLight":"#fae3c5","skinToneMediumLight":"#e2cfa5","skinToneMedium":"#daa478","skinToneMediumDark":"#a78058","skinToneDark":"#5e4d43","__typename":"EmojiThemeSettings"},"heading":{"color":"var(--lia-bs-body-color)","fontFamily":"Inter","fontStyle":"NORMAL","fontWeight":"600","h1FontSize":"30px","h2FontSize":"25px","h3FontSize":"20px","h4FontSize":"18px","h5FontSize":"16px","h6FontSize":"16px","lineHeight":"1.2","subHeaderFontSize":"11px","subHeaderFontWeight":"500","h1LetterSpacing":"normal","h2LetterSpacing":"normal","h3LetterSpacing":"normal","h4LetterSpacing":"normal","h5LetterSpacing":"normal","h6LetterSpacing":"normal","subHeaderLetterSpacing":"2px","h1FontWeight":"var(--lia-bs-headings-font-weight)","h2FontWeight":"var(--lia-bs-headings-font-weight)","h3FontWeight":"var(--lia-bs-headings-font-weight)","h4FontWeight":"var(--lia-bs-headings-font-weight)","h5FontWeight":"var(--lia-bs-headings-font-weight)","h6FontWeight":"var(--lia-bs-headings-font-weight)","__typename":"HeadingThemeSettings"},"icons":{"size10":"10px","size12":"12px","size14":"14px","size16":"16px","size20":"20px","size24":"24px","size30":"30px","size40":"40px","size50":"50px","size60":"60px","size80":"80px","size120":"120px","size160":"160px","__typename":"IconsThemeSettings"},"imagePreview":{"bgColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-900)","titleColor":"var(--lia-bs-white)","controlColor":"var(--lia-bs-white)","controlBgColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-800)","__typename":"ImagePreviewThemeSettings"},"input":{"borderColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-600)","disabledColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-600)","focusBorderColor":"var(--lia-bs-primary)","labelMarginBottom":"10px","btnFontSize":"var(--lia-bs-font-size-sm)","focusBoxShadow":"0 0 0 3px hsla(var(--lia-bs-primary-h), var(--lia-bs-primary-s), var(--lia-bs-primary-l), 0.2)","checkLabelMarginBottom":"2px","checkboxBorderRadius":"3px","borderRadiusSm":"var(--lia-bs-border-radius-sm)","borderRadius":"var(--lia-bs-border-radius)","borderRadiusLg":"var(--lia-bs-border-radius-lg)","formTextMarginTop":"4px","textAreaBorderRadius":"var(--lia-bs-border-radius)","activeFillColor":"var(--lia-bs-primary)","__typename":"InputThemeSettings"},"loading":{"dotDarkColor":"hsla(var(--lia-bs-black-h), var(--lia-bs-black-s), var(--lia-bs-black-l), 0.2)","dotLightColor":"hsla(var(--lia-bs-white-h), var(--lia-bs-white-s), var(--lia-bs-white-l), 0.5)","barDarkColor":"hsla(var(--lia-bs-black-h), var(--lia-bs-black-s), var(--lia-bs-black-l), 0.06)","barLightColor":"hsla(var(--lia-bs-white-h), var(--lia-bs-white-s), var(--lia-bs-white-l), 0.4)","__typename":"LoadingThemeSettings"},"link":{"color":"var(--lia-bs-primary)","hoverColor":"hsl(var(--lia-bs-primary-h), var(--lia-bs-primary-s), calc(var(--lia-bs-primary-l) - 10%))","decoration":"none","hoverDecoration":"underline","__typename":"LinkThemeSettings"},"listGroup":{"itemPaddingY":"15px","itemPaddingX":"15px","borderColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-300)","__typename":"ListGroupThemeSettings"},"modal":{"contentTextColor":"var(--lia-bs-body-color)","contentBg":"var(--lia-bs-white)","backgroundBg":"var(--lia-bs-black)","smSize":"440px","mdSize":"760px","lgSize":"1080px","backdropOpacity":0.3,"contentBoxShadowXs":"var(--lia-bs-box-shadow-sm)","contentBoxShadow":"var(--lia-bs-box-shadow)","headerFontWeight":"700","__typename":"ModalThemeSettings"},"navbar":{"position":"FIXED","background":{"attachment":null,"clip":null,"color":"var(--lia-bs-white)","imageAssetName":null,"imageLastModified":"0","origin":null,"position":"CENTER_CENTER","repeat":"NO_REPEAT","size":"COVER","__typename":"BackgroundProps"},"backgroundOpacity":0.8,"paddingTop":"15px","paddingBottom":"15px","borderBottom":"1px solid var(--lia-bs-border-color)","boxShadow":"var(--lia-bs-box-shadow-sm)","brandMarginRight":"30px","brandMarginRightSm":"10px","brandLogoHeight":"30px","linkGap":"10px","linkJustifyContent":"flex-start","linkPaddingY":"5px","linkPaddingX":"10px","linkDropdownPaddingY":"9px","linkDropdownPaddingX":"var(--lia-nav-link-px)","linkColor":"var(--lia-bs-body-color)","linkHoverColor":"var(--lia-bs-primary)","linkFontSize":"var(--lia-bs-font-size-sm)","linkFontStyle":"NORMAL","linkFontWeight":"400","linkTextTransform":"NONE","linkLetterSpacing":"normal","linkBorderRadius":"var(--lia-bs-border-radius-sm)","linkBgColor":"transparent","linkBgHoverColor":"transparent","linkBorder":"none","linkBorderHover":"none","linkBoxShadow":"none","linkBoxShadowHover":"none","linkTextBorderBottom":"none","linkTextBorderBottomHover":"none","dropdownPaddingTop":"10px","dropdownPaddingBottom":"15px","dropdownPaddingX":"10px","dropdownMenuOffset":"2px","dropdownDividerMarginTop":"10px","dropdownDividerMarginBottom":"10px","dropdownBorderColor":"hsla(var(--lia-bs-black-h), var(--lia-bs-black-s), var(--lia-bs-black-l), 0.08)","controllerBgHoverColor":"hsla(var(--lia-bs-black-h), var(--lia-bs-black-s), var(--lia-bs-black-l), 0.1)","controllerIconColor":"var(--lia-bs-body-color)","controllerIconHoverColor":"var(--lia-bs-body-color)","controllerTextColor":"var(--lia-nav-controller-icon-color)","controllerTextHoverColor":"var(--lia-nav-controller-icon-hover-color)","controllerHighlightColor":"hsla(30, 100%, 50%)","controllerHighlightTextColor":"var(--lia-yiq-light)","controllerBorderRadius":"var(--lia-border-radius-50)","hamburgerColor":"var(--lia-nav-controller-icon-color)","hamburgerHoverColor":"var(--lia-nav-controller-icon-color)","hamburgerBgColor":"transparent","hamburgerBgHoverColor":"transparent","hamburgerBorder":"none","hamburgerBorderHover":"none","collapseMenuMarginLeft":"20px","collapseMenuDividerBg":"var(--lia-nav-link-color)","collapseMenuDividerOpacity":0.16,"__typename":"NavbarThemeSettings"},"pager":{"textColor":"var(--lia-bs-link-color)","textFontWeight":"var(--lia-font-weight-md)","textFontSize":"var(--lia-bs-font-size-sm)","__typename":"PagerThemeSettings"},"panel":{"bgColor":"var(--lia-bs-white)","borderRadius":"var(--lia-bs-border-radius)","borderColor":"var(--lia-bs-border-color)","boxShadow":"none","__typename":"PanelThemeSettings"},"popover":{"arrowHeight":"8px","arrowWidth":"16px","maxWidth":"300px","minWidth":"100px","headerBg":"var(--lia-bs-white)","borderColor":"var(--lia-bs-border-color)","borderRadius":"var(--lia-bs-border-radius)","boxShadow":"0 0.5rem 1rem hsla(var(--lia-bs-black-h), var(--lia-bs-black-s), var(--lia-bs-black-l), 0.15)","__typename":"PopoverThemeSettings"},"prism":{"color":"#000000","bgColor":"#f5f2f0","fontFamily":"var(--font-family-monospace)","fontSize":"var(--lia-bs-font-size-base)","fontWeightBold":"var(--lia-bs-font-weight-bold)","fontStyleItalic":"italic","tabSize":2,"highlightColor":"#b3d4fc","commentColor":"#62707e","punctuationColor":"#6f6f6f","namespaceOpacity":"0.7","propColor":"#990055","selectorColor":"#517a00","operatorColor":"#906736","operatorBgColor":"hsla(0, 0%, 100%, 0.5)","keywordColor":"#0076a9","functionColor":"#d3284b","variableColor":"#c14700","__typename":"PrismThemeSettings"},"rte":{"bgColor":"var(--lia-bs-white)","borderRadius":"var(--lia-panel-border-radius)","boxShadow":" var(--lia-panel-box-shadow)","customColor1":"#bfedd2","customColor2":"#fbeeb8","customColor3":"#f8cac6","customColor4":"#eccafa","customColor5":"#c2e0f4","customColor6":"#2dc26b","customColor7":"#f1c40f","customColor8":"#e03e2d","customColor9":"#b96ad9","customColor10":"#3598db","customColor11":"#169179","customColor12":"#e67e23","customColor13":"#ba372a","customColor14":"#843fa1","customColor15":"#236fa1","customColor16":"#ecf0f1","customColor17":"#ced4d9","customColor18":"#95a5a6","customColor19":"#7e8c8d","customColor20":"#34495e","customColor21":"#000000","customColor22":"#ffffff","defaultMessageHeaderMarginTop":"14px","defaultMessageHeaderMarginBottom":"10px","defaultMessageItemMarginTop":"0","defaultMessageItemMarginBottom":"10px","diffAddedColor":"hsla(170, 53%, 51%, 0.4)","diffChangedColor":"hsla(43, 97%, 63%, 0.4)","diffNoneColor":"hsla(0, 0%, 80%, 0.4)","diffRemovedColor":"hsla(9, 74%, 47%, 0.4)","specialMessageHeaderMarginTop":"14px","specialMessageHeaderMarginBottom":"10px","specialMessageItemMarginTop":"0","specialMessageItemMarginBottom":"10px","__typename":"RteThemeSettings"},"tags":{"bgColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-200)","bgHoverColor":"var(--lia-bs-gray-400)","borderRadius":"var(--lia-bs-border-radius-sm)","color":"var(--lia-bs-body-color)","hoverColor":"var(--lia-bs-body-color)","fontWeight":"var(--lia-font-weight-md)","fontSize":"var(--lia-font-size-xxs)","textTransform":"UPPERCASE","letterSpacing":"0.5px","__typename":"TagsThemeSettings"},"toasts":{"borderRadius":"var(--lia-bs-border-radius)","paddingX":"12px","__typename":"ToastsThemeSettings"},"typography":{"fontFamilyBase":"Atkinson Hyperlegible","fontStyleBase":"NORMAL","fontWeightBase":"400","fontWeightLight":"300","fontWeightNormal":"400","fontWeightMd":"500","fontWeightBold":"700","letterSpacingSm":"normal","letterSpacingXs":"normal","lineHeightBase":"1.3","fontSizeBase":"15px","fontSizeXxs":"11px","fontSizeXs":"12px","fontSizeSm":"13px","fontSizeLg":"20px","fontSizeXl":"24px","smallFontSize":"14px","customFonts":[],"__typename":"TypographyThemeSettings"},"unstyledListItem":{"marginBottomSm":"5px","marginBottomMd":"10px","marginBottomLg":"15px","marginBottomXl":"20px","marginBottomXxl":"25px","__typename":"UnstyledListItemThemeSettings"},"yiq":{"light":"#ffffff","dark":"#000000","__typename":"YiqThemeSettings"},"colorLightness":{"primaryDark":0.36,"primaryLight":0.74,"primaryLighter":0.89,"primaryLightest":0.95,"infoDark":0.39,"infoLight":0.72,"infoLighter":0.85,"infoLightest":0.93,"successDark":0.24,"successLight":0.62,"successLighter":0.8,"successLightest":0.91,"warningDark":0.39,"warningLight":0.68,"warningLighter":0.84,"warningLightest":0.93,"dangerDark":0.41,"dangerLight":0.72,"dangerLighter":0.89,"dangerLightest":0.95,"__typename":"ColorLightnessThemeSettings"},"localOverride":false,"__typename":"Theme"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/common/Loading/LoadingDot-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/common/Loading/LoadingDot-1745595729370","value":{"title":"Loading..."},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:quilt:f5.prod:pages/forums/ForumMessagePage:board:TechnicalForum-1745595726105":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"quilt:f5.prod:pages/forums/ForumMessagePage:board:TechnicalForum-1745595726105","value":{"id":"ForumMessagePage","container":{"id":"Common","headerProps":{"backgroundImageProps":null,"backgroundColor":null,"addComponents":null,"removeComponents":["community.widget.bannerWidget"],"componentOrder":null,"__typename":"QuiltContainerSectionProps"},"headerComponentProps":{"community.widget.breadcrumbWidget":{"disableLastCrumbForDesktop":false}},"footerProps":null,"footerComponentProps":null,"items":[{"id":"message-list","layout":"MAIN_SIDE","bgColor":null,"showTitle":null,"showDescription":null,"textPosition":null,"textColor":null,"sectionEditLevel":null,"bgImage":null,"disableSpacing":null,"edgeToEdgeDisplay":null,"fullHeight":null,"showBorder":null,"__typename":"MainSideQuiltSection","columnMap":{"main":[{"id":"messages.widget.topicWithThreadedReplyListWidget","className":"lia-topic-with-replies","props":{"editLevel":"CONFIGURE"},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"}],"side":[{"id":"featuredWidgets.widget.featuredContentWidget","className":null,"props":{"instanceId":"featuredWidgets.widget.featuredContentWidget-1705956211049","layoutProps":{"layout":"card","layoutOptions":{"useRepliesCount":false,"useAuthorRank":false,"useTimeToRead":true,"useKudosCount":false,"useViewCount":false,"usePreviewMedia":true,"useBody":false,"useCenteredCardContent":false,"useTags":true,"useTimestamp":false,"useBoardLink":true,"useAuthorLink":false,"useSolvedBadge":true}},"titleSrOnly":false,"showPager":true,"pageSize":3,"lazyLoad":false},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"},{"id":"messages.widget.messageListForNodeByRecentActivityWidget","className":null,"props":{"hideIfEmpty":true,"pageSize":5,"pagerVariant":{"type":"loadMore"},"viewVariant":{"type":"inline","props":{"useRepliesCount":false,"useMedia":false,"useAuthorRank":false,"useNode":false,"boardIconSize":"24","truncateBodyLength":-1,"useNodeLink":true,"usePreviewMedia":false,"timeStampType":"conversation.lastPostingActivityTime","avatarSize":"40","useTextBody":true,"useSolvedBadge":true,"subjectAs":"h6","renderPostTimeBeforeAuthor":true,"useAvatar":false,"useTimeToRead":false,"useSpoilerFreeBody":true,"useKudosCount":false,"useViewCount":false,"useBody":false,"useTags":false,"clampSubjectLines":1,"useBoardIcon":true,"useMessageTimeLink":true,"clampBodyLines":3,"useAuthorLogin":true,"useUnreadCount":false,"useNodeHoverCard":true,"useSearchSnippet":false}},"lazyLoad":false,"listVariant":{"type":"unstyled","props":{"listItemSpacing":"xxl"}},"useTitle":true,"addTags":false,"titleContextVariant":"other","showTabs":false,"style":"compact","panelType":"standard","sorts":{"conversationLastPostingActivityTime":{"direction":"DESC"}}},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"},{"id":"messages.widget.relatedContentWidget","className":null,"props":{"hideIfEmpty":true,"enablePagination":false,"useTitle":true,"listVariant":{"type":"unstyled","props":{"listItemSpacing":"xxl"}},"pageSize":5,"style":"compact","pagerVariant":{"type":"none"},"viewVariant":{"type":"inline","props":{"useRepliesCount":false,"useMedia":false,"useAuthorRank":false,"useNode":false,"boardIconSize":"24","useAuthorLoginLink":true,"useNodeLink":true,"usePreviewMedia":true,"timeStampType":"postTime","useTextBody":true,"useSolvedBadge":false,"subjectAs":"h6","renderPostTimeBeforeAuthor":true,"useAvatar":false,"useVideoPreview":false,"portraitClampBodyLines":3,"useCompactSpacing":true,"useTimeToRead":false,"useSpoilerFreeBody":true,"useKudosCount":false,"useViewCount":false,"useBody":false,"useTags":false,"clampSubjectLines":1,"useBoardIcon":true,"useMessageTimeLink":true,"useAuthorLogin":true}},"lazyLoad":false,"panelType":"standard"},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"},{"id":"custom.widget.Community_Quicklinks","className":null,"props":{"customComponentId":"custom.widget.Community_Quicklinks"},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"}],"__typename":"MainSideSectionColumns"}}],"__typename":"QuiltContainer"},"__typename":"Quilt","localOverride":false},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/common/EmailVerification-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/common/EmailVerification-1745595729370","value":{"email.verification.title":"Email Verification Required","email.verification.message.update.email":"To participate in the community, you must first verify your email address. The verification email was sent to {email}. To change your email, visit My Settings.","email.verification.message.resend.email":"To participate in the community, you must first verify your email address. The verification email was sent to {email}. Resend email."},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-pages/forums/ForumMessagePage-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-pages/forums/ForumMessagePage-1745595729370","value":{"title":"{contextMessageSubject} | {communityTitle}","errorMissing":"This message cannot be found","name":"Forum Message Page","section.message-list.title":"Forum Discussion","archivedMessageTitle":"This Content Has Been Archived"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/common/ActionFeedback-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/common/ActionFeedback-1745595729370","value":{"joinedGroupHub.title":"Welcome","joinedGroupHub.message":"You are now a member of this group and are subscribed to updates.","groupHubInviteNotFound.title":"Invitation Not Found","groupHubInviteNotFound.message":"Sorry, we could not find your invitation to the group. The owner may have canceled the invite.","groupHubNotFound.title":"Group Not Found","groupHubNotFound.message":"The grouphub you tried to join does not exist. It may have been deleted.","existingGroupHubMember.title":"Already Joined","existingGroupHubMember.message":"You are already a member of this group.","accountLocked.title":"Account Locked","accountLocked.message":"Your account has been locked due to multiple failed attempts. Try again in {lockoutTime} minutes.","editedGroupHub.title":"Changes Saved","editedGroupHub.message":"Your group has been updated.","leftGroupHub.title":"Goodbye","leftGroupHub.message":"You are no longer a member of this group and will not receive future updates.","deletedGroupHub.title":"Deleted","deletedGroupHub.message":"The group has been deleted.","groupHubCreated.title":"Group Created","groupHubCreated.message":"{groupHubName} is ready to use","accountClosed.title":"Account Closed","accountClosed.message":"The account has been closed and you will now be redirected to the homepage","resetTokenExpired.title":"Reset Password Link has Expired","resetTokenExpired.message":"Try resetting your password again","invalidUrl.title":"Invalid URL","invalidUrl.message":"The URL you're using is not recognized. Verify your URL and try again.","accountClosedForUser.title":"Account Closed","accountClosedForUser.message":"{userName}'s account is closed","inviteTokenInvalid.title":"Invitation Invalid","inviteTokenInvalid.message":"Your invitation to the community has been canceled or expired.","inviteTokenError.title":"Invitation Verification Failed","inviteTokenError.message":"The url you are utilizing is not recognized. Verify your URL and try again","pageNotFound.title":"Access Denied","pageNotFound.message":"You do not have access to this area of the community or it doesn't exist","eventAttending.title":"Responded as Attending","eventAttending.message":"You'll be notified when there's new activity and reminded as the event approaches","eventInterested.title":"Responded as Interested","eventInterested.message":"You'll be notified when there's new activity and reminded as the event approaches","eventNotFound.title":"Event Not Found","eventNotFound.message":"The event you tried to respond to does not exist.","redirectToRelatedPage.title":"Showing Related Content","redirectToRelatedPageForBaseUsers.title":"Showing Related Content","redirectToRelatedPageForBaseUsers.message":"The content you are trying to access is archived","redirectToRelatedPage.message":"The content you are trying to access is archived","relatedUrl.archivalLink.flyoutMessage":"The content you are trying to access is archived View Archived Content"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:quiltWrapper:f5.prod:Common:1745595708561":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"quiltWrapper:f5.prod:Common:1745595708561","value":{"id":"Common","header":{"backgroundImageProps":{"assetName":"header.jpg","backgroundSize":"COVER","backgroundRepeat":"NO_REPEAT","backgroundPosition":"LEFT_CENTER","lastModified":"1702932449000","__typename":"BackgroundImageProps"},"backgroundColor":"transparent","items":[{"id":"custom.widget.GainsightShared","props":{"widgetVisibility":"signedInOnly","useTitle":true,"useBackground":false,"title":"","lazyLoad":false},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"},{"id":"custom.widget.Beta_MetaNav","props":{"widgetVisibility":"signedInOrAnonymous","useTitle":true,"useBackground":false,"title":"","lazyLoad":false},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"},{"id":"community.widget.navbarWidget","props":{"showUserName":false,"showRegisterLink":true,"style":{"boxShadow":"var(--lia-bs-box-shadow-sm)","linkFontWeight":"700","controllerHighlightColor":"hsla(30, 100%, 50%)","dropdownDividerMarginBottom":"10px","hamburgerBorderHover":"none","linkFontSize":"15px","linkBoxShadowHover":"none","backgroundOpacity":0.4,"controllerBorderRadius":"var(--lia-border-radius-50)","hamburgerBgColor":"transparent","linkTextBorderBottom":"none","hamburgerColor":"var(--lia-nav-controller-icon-color)","brandLogoHeight":"48px","linkLetterSpacing":"normal","linkBgHoverColor":"transparent","collapseMenuDividerOpacity":0.16,"paddingBottom":"10px","dropdownPaddingBottom":"15px","dropdownMenuOffset":"2px","hamburgerBgHoverColor":"transparent","borderBottom":"0","hamburgerBorder":"none","dropdownPaddingX":"10px","brandMarginRightSm":"10px","linkBoxShadow":"none","linkJustifyContent":"center","linkColor":"var(--lia-bs-primary)","collapseMenuDividerBg":"var(--lia-nav-link-color)","dropdownPaddingTop":"10px","controllerHighlightTextColor":"var(--lia-yiq-dark)","background":{"imageAssetName":"","color":"var(--lia-bs-white)","size":"COVER","repeat":"NO_REPEAT","position":"CENTER_CENTER","imageLastModified":""},"linkBorderRadius":"var(--lia-bs-border-radius-sm)","linkHoverColor":"var(--lia-bs-primary)","position":"FIXED","linkBorder":"none","linkTextBorderBottomHover":"2px solid #0C5C8D","brandMarginRight":"30px","hamburgerHoverColor":"var(--lia-nav-controller-icon-color)","linkBorderHover":"none","collapseMenuMarginLeft":"20px","linkFontStyle":"NORMAL","linkPaddingX":"10px","paddingTop":"10px","linkPaddingY":"5px","linkTextTransform":"NONE","dropdownBorderColor":"hsla(var(--lia-bs-black-h), var(--lia-bs-black-s), var(--lia-bs-black-l), 0.08)","controllerBgHoverColor":"hsla(var(--lia-bs-black-h), var(--lia-bs-black-s), var(--lia-bs-black-l), 0.1)","linkDropdownPaddingX":"var(--lia-nav-link-px)","linkBgColor":"transparent","linkDropdownPaddingY":"9px","controllerIconColor":"#0C5C8D","dropdownDividerMarginTop":"10px","linkGap":"10px","controllerIconHoverColor":"#0C5C8D"},"links":{"sideLinks":[],"mainLinks":[{"children":[{"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-1","params":{"boardId":"TechnicalForum","categoryId":"Forums"},"routeName":"ForumBoardPage"},{"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-2","params":{"boardId":"WaterCooler","categoryId":"Forums"},"routeName":"ForumBoardPage"}],"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-0","params":{"categoryId":"Forums"},"routeName":"CategoryPage"},{"children":[{"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-4","params":{"boardId":"codeshare","categoryId":"CrowdSRC"},"routeName":"TkbBoardPage"},{"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-5","params":{"boardId":"communityarticles","categoryId":"CrowdSRC"},"routeName":"TkbBoardPage"}],"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-3","params":{"categoryId":"CrowdSRC"},"routeName":"CategoryPage"},{"children":[{"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-7","params":{"boardId":"TechnicalArticles","categoryId":"Articles"},"routeName":"TkbBoardPage"},{"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"article-series","params":{"boardId":"article-series","categoryId":"Articles"},"routeName":"TkbBoardPage"},{"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"security-insights","params":{"boardId":"security-insights","categoryId":"Articles"},"routeName":"TkbBoardPage"},{"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-8","params":{"boardId":"DevCentralNews","categoryId":"Articles"},"routeName":"TkbBoardPage"}],"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-6","params":{"categoryId":"Articles"},"routeName":"CategoryPage"},{"children":[{"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-10","params":{"categoryId":"CommunityGroups"},"routeName":"CategoryPage"},{"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-11","params":{"categoryId":"F5-Groups"},"routeName":"CategoryPage"}],"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-9","params":{"categoryId":"GroupsCategory"},"routeName":"CategoryPage"},{"children":[],"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-12","params":{"boardId":"Events","categoryId":"top"},"routeName":"EventBoardPage"},{"children":[],"linkType":"INTERNAL","id":"migrated-link-13","params":{"boardId":"Suggestions","categoryId":"top"},"routeName":"IdeaBoardPage"},{"children":[],"linkType":"EXTERNAL","id":"Common-external-link","url":"https://community.f5.com/c/how-do-i","target":"SELF"}]},"className":"QuiltComponent_lia-component-edit-mode__lQ9Z6","showSearchIcon":false},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"},{"id":"community.widget.bannerWidget","props":{"backgroundColor":"transparent","visualEffects":{"showBottomBorder":false},"backgroundImageProps":{"backgroundSize":"COVER","backgroundPosition":"CENTER_CENTER","backgroundRepeat":"NO_REPEAT"},"fontColor":"#222222"},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"},{"id":"community.widget.breadcrumbWidget","props":{"backgroundColor":"var(--lia-bs-primary)","linkHighlightColor":"#FFFFFF","visualEffects":{"showBottomBorder":false},"backgroundOpacity":60,"linkTextColor":"#FFFFFF"},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"}],"__typename":"QuiltWrapperSection"},"footer":{"backgroundImageProps":{"assetName":null,"backgroundSize":"COVER","backgroundRepeat":"NO_REPEAT","backgroundPosition":"CENTER_CENTER","lastModified":null,"__typename":"BackgroundImageProps"},"backgroundColor":"var(--lia-bs-body-color)","items":[{"id":"custom.widget.Beta_Footer","props":{"widgetVisibility":"signedInOrAnonymous","useTitle":true,"useBackground":false,"title":"","lazyLoad":false},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"},{"id":"custom.widget.Tag_Manager_Helper","props":{"widgetVisibility":"signedInOrAnonymous","useTitle":true,"useBackground":false,"title":"","lazyLoad":false},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"},{"id":"custom.widget.Consent_Blackbar","props":{"widgetVisibility":"signedInOrAnonymous","useTitle":true,"useBackground":false,"title":"","lazyLoad":false},"__typename":"QuiltComponent"}],"__typename":"QuiltWrapperSection"},"__typename":"QuiltWrapper","localOverride":false},"localOverride":false},"QueryVariables:TopicReplyList:message:202123:1":{"__typename":"QueryVariables","id":"TopicReplyList:message:202123:1","value":{"id":"message:202123","first":10,"sorts":{"postTime":{"direction":"ASC"}},"repliesFirst":3,"repliesFirstDepthThree":1,"repliesSorts":{"postTime":{"direction":"ASC"}},"useAvatar":true,"useAuthorLogin":true,"useAuthorRank":true,"useBody":true,"useKudosCount":true,"useTimeToRead":false,"useMedia":false,"useReadOnlyIcon":false,"useRepliesCount":true,"useSearchSnippet":false,"useAcceptedSolutionButton":true,"useSolvedBadge":false,"useAttachments":false,"attachmentsFirst":5,"useTags":true,"useNodeAncestors":false,"useUserHoverCard":false,"useNodeHoverCard":false,"useModerationStatus":true,"usePreviewSubjectModal":false,"useMessageStatus":true}},"ROOT_MUTATION":{"__typename":"Mutation"},"CachedAsset:component:custom.widget.GainsightShared-en-us-1745595734006":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"component:custom.widget.GainsightShared-en-us-1745595734006","value":{"component":{"id":"custom.widget.GainsightShared","template":{"id":"GainsightShared","markupLanguage":"HTML","style":null,"texts":{},"defaults":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"Shared functions for Gainsight integration","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"components":[{"id":"custom.widget.GainsightShared","form":null,"config":null,"props":[],"__typename":"Component"}],"grouping":"TEXTHTML","__typename":"ComponentTemplate"},"properties":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"Shared functions for Gainsight integration","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"form":null,"__typename":"Component","localOverride":false},"globalCss":null,"form":null},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:component:custom.widget.Beta_MetaNav-en-us-1745595734006":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"component:custom.widget.Beta_MetaNav-en-us-1745595734006","value":{"component":{"id":"custom.widget.Beta_MetaNav","template":{"id":"Beta_MetaNav","markupLanguage":"HANDLEBARS","style":null,"texts":{},"defaults":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"MetaNav menu at the top of every page.","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"components":[{"id":"custom.widget.Beta_MetaNav","form":null,"config":null,"props":[],"__typename":"Component"}],"grouping":"CUSTOM","__typename":"ComponentTemplate"},"properties":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"MetaNav menu at the top of every page.","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"form":null,"__typename":"Component","localOverride":false},"globalCss":null,"form":null},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:component:custom.widget.Community_Quicklinks-en-us-1745595734006":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"component:custom.widget.Community_Quicklinks-en-us-1745595734006","value":{"component":{"id":"custom.widget.Community_Quicklinks","template":{"id":"Community_Quicklinks","markupLanguage":"HANDLEBARS","style":null,"texts":{},"defaults":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"components":[{"id":"custom.widget.Community_Quicklinks","form":null,"config":null,"props":[],"__typename":"Component"}],"grouping":"CUSTOM","__typename":"ComponentTemplate"},"properties":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"form":null,"__typename":"Component","localOverride":false},"globalCss":null,"form":null},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:component:custom.widget.Beta_Footer-en-us-1745595734006":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"component:custom.widget.Beta_Footer-en-us-1745595734006","value":{"component":{"id":"custom.widget.Beta_Footer","template":{"id":"Beta_Footer","markupLanguage":"HANDLEBARS","style":null,"texts":{},"defaults":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"DevCentral´s custom footer.","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"components":[{"id":"custom.widget.Beta_Footer","form":null,"config":null,"props":[],"__typename":"Component"}],"grouping":"CUSTOM","__typename":"ComponentTemplate"},"properties":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"DevCentral´s custom footer.","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"form":null,"__typename":"Component","localOverride":false},"globalCss":null,"form":null},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:component:custom.widget.Tag_Manager_Helper-en-us-1745595734006":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"component:custom.widget.Tag_Manager_Helper-en-us-1745595734006","value":{"component":{"id":"custom.widget.Tag_Manager_Helper","template":{"id":"Tag_Manager_Helper","markupLanguage":"HANDLEBARS","style":null,"texts":{},"defaults":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"Helper widget to inject Tag Manager scripts into head element","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"components":[{"id":"custom.widget.Tag_Manager_Helper","form":null,"config":null,"props":[],"__typename":"Component"}],"grouping":"CUSTOM","__typename":"ComponentTemplate"},"properties":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"Helper widget to inject Tag Manager scripts into head element","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"form":null,"__typename":"Component","localOverride":false},"globalCss":null,"form":null},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:component:custom.widget.Consent_Blackbar-en-us-1745595734006":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"component:custom.widget.Consent_Blackbar-en-us-1745595734006","value":{"component":{"id":"custom.widget.Consent_Blackbar","template":{"id":"Consent_Blackbar","markupLanguage":"HTML","style":null,"texts":{},"defaults":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"components":[{"id":"custom.widget.Consent_Blackbar","form":null,"config":null,"props":[],"__typename":"Component"}],"grouping":"TEXTHTML","__typename":"ComponentTemplate"},"properties":{"config":{"applicablePages":[],"description":"","fetchedContent":null,"__typename":"ComponentConfiguration"},"props":[],"__typename":"ComponentProperties"},"form":null,"__typename":"Component","localOverride":false},"globalCss":null,"form":null},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/community/Breadcrumb-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/community/Breadcrumb-1745595729370","value":{"navLabel":"Breadcrumbs","dropdown":"Additional parent page navigation"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageBanner-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageBanner-1745595729370","value":{"messageMarkedAsSpam":"This post has been marked as spam","messageMarkedAsSpam@board:TKB":"This article has been marked as spam","messageMarkedAsSpam@board:BLOG":"This post has been marked as spam","messageMarkedAsSpam@board:FORUM":"This discussion has been marked as spam","messageMarkedAsSpam@board:OCCASION":"This event has been marked as spam","messageMarkedAsSpam@board:IDEA":"This idea has been marked as spam","manageSpam":"Manage Spam","messageMarkedAsAbuse":"This post has been marked as abuse","messageMarkedAsAbuse@board:TKB":"This article has been marked as abuse","messageMarkedAsAbuse@board:BLOG":"This post has been marked as abuse","messageMarkedAsAbuse@board:FORUM":"This discussion has been marked as abuse","messageMarkedAsAbuse@board:OCCASION":"This event has been marked as abuse","messageMarkedAsAbuse@board:IDEA":"This idea has been marked as abuse","preModCommentAuthorText":"This comment will be published as soon as it is approved","preModCommentModeratorText":"This comment is awaiting moderation","messageMarkedAsOther":"This post has been rejected due to other reasons","messageMarkedAsOther@board:TKB":"This article has been rejected due to other reasons","messageMarkedAsOther@board:BLOG":"This post has been rejected due to other reasons","messageMarkedAsOther@board:FORUM":"This discussion has been rejected due to other reasons","messageMarkedAsOther@board:OCCASION":"This event has been rejected due to other reasons","messageMarkedAsOther@board:IDEA":"This idea has been rejected due to other reasons","messageArchived":"This post was archived on {date}","relatedUrl":"View Related Content","relatedContentText":"Showing related content","archivedContentLink":"View Archived Content"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewStandard-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewStandard-1745595729370","value":{"anonymous":"Anonymous","author":"{messageAuthorLogin}","authorBy":"{messageAuthorLogin}","board":"{messageBoardTitle}","replyToUser":" to {parentAuthor}","showMoreReplies":"Show More","replyText":"Reply","repliesText":"Replies","markedAsSolved":"Marked as Solution","movedMessagePlaceholder.BLOG":"{count, plural, =0 {This comment has been} other {These comments have been} }","movedMessagePlaceholder.TKB":"{count, plural, =0 {This comment has been} other {These comments have been} }","movedMessagePlaceholder.FORUM":"{count, plural, =0 {This reply has been} other {These replies have been} }","movedMessagePlaceholder.IDEA":"{count, plural, =0 {This comment has been} other {These comments have been} }","movedMessagePlaceholder.OCCASION":"{count, plural, =0 {This comment has been} other {These comments have been} }","movedMessagePlaceholderUrlText":"moved.","messageStatus":"Status: ","statusChanged":"Status changed: {previousStatus} to {currentStatus}","statusAdded":"Status added: {status}","statusRemoved":"Status removed: {status}","labelExpand":"expand replies","labelCollapse":"collapse replies","unhelpfulReason.reason1":"Content is outdated","unhelpfulReason.reason2":"Article is missing information","unhelpfulReason.reason3":"Content is for a different Product","unhelpfulReason.reason4":"Doesn't match what I was searching for"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/ThreadedReplyList-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/ThreadedReplyList-1745595729370","value":{"title":"{count, plural, one{# Reply} other{# Replies}}","title@board:BLOG":"{count, plural, one{# Comment} other{# Comments}}","title@board:TKB":"{count, plural, one{# Comment} other{# Comments}}","title@board:IDEA":"{count, plural, one{# Comment} other{# Comments}}","title@board:OCCASION":"{count, plural, one{# Comment} other{# Comments}}","noRepliesTitle":"No Replies","noRepliesTitle@board:BLOG":"No Comments","noRepliesTitle@board:TKB":"No Comments","noRepliesTitle@board:IDEA":"No Comments","noRepliesTitle@board:OCCASION":"No Comments","noRepliesDescription":"Be the first to reply","noRepliesDescription@board:BLOG":"Be the first to comment","noRepliesDescription@board:TKB":"Be the first to comment","noRepliesDescription@board:IDEA":"Be the first to comment","noRepliesDescription@board:OCCASION":"Be the first to comment","messageReadOnlyAlert:BLOG":"Comments have been turned off for this post","messageReadOnlyAlert:TKB":"Comments have been turned off for this article","messageReadOnlyAlert:IDEA":"Comments have been turned off for this idea","messageReadOnlyAlert:FORUM":"Replies have been turned off for this discussion","messageReadOnlyAlert:OCCASION":"Comments have been turned off for this event"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageReplyCallToAction-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageReplyCallToAction-1745595729370","value":{"leaveReply":"Leave a reply...","leaveReply@board:BLOG@message:root":"Leave a comment...","leaveReply@board:TKB@message:root":"Leave a comment...","leaveReply@board:IDEA@message:root":"Leave a comment...","leaveReply@board:OCCASION@message:root":"Leave a comment...","repliesTurnedOff.FORUM":"Replies are turned off for this topic","repliesTurnedOff.BLOG":"Comments are turned off for this topic","repliesTurnedOff.TKB":"Comments are turned off for this topic","repliesTurnedOff.IDEA":"Comments are turned off for this topic","repliesTurnedOff.OCCASION":"Comments are turned off for this topic","infoText":"Stop poking me!"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/featured/content/FeaturedContentWidget-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/featured/content/FeaturedContentWidget-1745595729370","value":{"edit":"Edit Featured Content","title":"Featured Content","title@instance:iLVTsW":"Pinned Items","title@instance:featuredWidgets.widget.featuredContentWidget-1702666903735":"","title@instance:TZsNhL":"","title@instance:featuredWidgets.widget.featuredContentWidget-1702666556326":"","title@instance:featuredWidgets.widget.featuredContentWidget-1717525242793":"","title@instance:featuredWidgets.widget.featuredContentWidget-1705956211049":"","title@instance:featuredWidgets.widget.featuredContentWidget-1717525727595":"Pinned Items","title@instance:featuredWidgets.widget.featuredContentWidget-1728320145294":"Pinned Items","title@instance:featuredWidgets.widget.featuredContentWidget-1703882552800":""},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageListForNodeByRecentActivityWidget-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageListForNodeByRecentActivityWidget-1745595729370","value":{"title@userScope:other":"Recent Content","title@userScope:self":"Contributions","title@board:FORUM@userScope:other":"Recent Discussions","title@board:BLOG@userScope:other":"Recent Blogs","emptyDescription":"No content to show","MessageListForNodeByRecentActivityWidgetEditor.nodeScope.label":"Scope","title@instance:1706288370055":"Content Feed","title@instance:1743095186784":"Most Recent Updates","title@instance:1704317906837":"Content Feed","title@instance:1743095018194":"Most Recent Updates","title@instance:1702668293472":"Community Feed","title@instance:1743095117047":"Most Recent Updates","title@instance:1704319314827":"Blog Feed","title@instance:1743095235555":"Most Recent Updates","title@instance:1704320290851":"My Contributions","title@instance:1703720491809":"Forum Feed","title@instance:1743095311723":"Most Recent Updates","title@instance:1703028709746":"Group Content Feed","title@instance:VTsglH":"Content Feed"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/RelatedContentWidget-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/RelatedContentWidget-1745595729370","value":{"title":"Related Content","emptyDescription":"No content to show"},"localOverride":false},"Forum:board:WaterCooler":{"__typename":"Forum","id":"board:WaterCooler","forumPolicies":{"__typename":"ForumPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"boardPolicies":{"__typename":"BoardPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}}},"Category:category:Articles":{"__typename":"Category","id":"category:Articles","categoryPolicies":{"__typename":"CategoryPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"entityType":"CATEGORY","displayId":"Articles","nodeType":"category","depth":1,"title":"Articles","shortTitle":"Articles"},"Tkb:board:TechnicalArticles":{"__typename":"Tkb","id":"board:TechnicalArticles","tkbPolicies":{"__typename":"TkbPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"boardPolicies":{"__typename":"BoardPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}}},"Tkb:board:DevCentralNews":{"__typename":"Tkb","id":"board:DevCentralNews","tkbPolicies":{"__typename":"TkbPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"boardPolicies":{"__typename":"BoardPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"entityType":"TKB","displayId":"DevCentralNews","nodeType":"board","depth":2,"conversationStyle":"TKB","title":"DevCentral News","shortTitle":"DevCentral News","parent":{"__ref":"Category:category:Articles"},"userContext":{"__typename":"NodeUserContext","canAddAttachments":false,"canUpdateNode":false,"canPostMessages":false,"isSubscribed":false},"avatar":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi0zNi02aTlBNjU5MTlBODIzNDE3MDM\"}"},"description":"Wherein we talk amongst ourselves.","eventPath":"category:Articles/community:zihoc95639board:DevCentralNews/"},"Category:category:GroupsCategory":{"__typename":"Category","id":"category:GroupsCategory","categoryPolicies":{"__typename":"CategoryPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}}},"Category:category:F5-Groups":{"__typename":"Category","id":"category:F5-Groups","categoryPolicies":{"__typename":"CategoryPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}}},"Category:category:CommunityGroups":{"__typename":"Category","id":"category:CommunityGroups","categoryPolicies":{"__typename":"CategoryPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}}},"Occasion:board:Events":{"__typename":"Occasion","id":"board:Events","boardPolicies":{"__typename":"BoardPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"occasionPolicies":{"__typename":"OccasionPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}}},"Idea:board:Suggestions":{"__typename":"Idea","id":"board:Suggestions","boardPolicies":{"__typename":"BoardPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"ideaPolicies":{"__typename":"IdeaPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}}},"Category:category:CrowdSRC":{"__typename":"Category","id":"category:CrowdSRC","categoryPolicies":{"__typename":"CategoryPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"entityType":"CATEGORY","displayId":"CrowdSRC","nodeType":"category","depth":1,"title":"CrowdSRC","shortTitle":"CrowdSRC"},"Tkb:board:codeshare":{"__typename":"Tkb","id":"board:codeshare","tkbPolicies":{"__typename":"TkbPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"boardPolicies":{"__typename":"BoardPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"entityType":"TKB","displayId":"codeshare","nodeType":"board","depth":2,"conversationStyle":"TKB","title":"CodeShare","shortTitle":"CodeShare","parent":{"__ref":"Category:category:CrowdSRC"},"userContext":{"__typename":"NodeUserContext","canAddAttachments":false,"canUpdateNode":false,"canPostMessages":false,"isSubscribed":false},"avatar":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi04Ny0xOTQ1NWk4ODNCOUNEMkFDNDZCQjI0\"}"},"description":"Have some code. Share some code.","eventPath":"category:CrowdSRC/community:zihoc95639board:codeshare/"},"Tkb:board:communityarticles":{"__typename":"Tkb","id":"board:communityarticles","tkbPolicies":{"__typename":"TkbPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"boardPolicies":{"__typename":"BoardPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"entityType":"TKB","displayId":"communityarticles","nodeType":"board","depth":2,"conversationStyle":"TKB","title":"Community Articles","shortTitle":"Community Articles","parent":{"__ref":"Category:category:CrowdSRC"},"userContext":{"__typename":"NodeUserContext","canAddAttachments":false,"canUpdateNode":false,"canPostMessages":false,"isSubscribed":false},"avatar":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi04OC0xOTQ1Nmk4RjgxOUIyQTAyRkFEMjdB\"}"},"description":"Freeform articles, written by members of the community.","eventPath":"category:CrowdSRC/community:zihoc95639board:communityarticles/"},"Tkb:board:security-insights":{"__typename":"Tkb","id":"board:security-insights","tkbPolicies":{"__typename":"TkbPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"boardPolicies":{"__typename":"BoardPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}}},"Tkb:board:article-series":{"__typename":"Tkb","id":"board:article-series","tkbPolicies":{"__typename":"TkbPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}},"boardPolicies":{"__typename":"BoardPolicies","canReadNode":{"__typename":"PolicyResult","failureReason":null}}},"Conversation:conversation:341049":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:341049","topic":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","uid":341049},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2025-04-29T06:03:44.128-07:00","solved":false},"ForumTopicMessage:message:341049":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","subject":"Sending an HTTP request from iRule without delaying client requests","conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:341049"},"id":"message:341049","revisionNum":1,"uid":341049,"depth":0,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"author":{"__typename":"User","uid":435630,"login":"iruleyourulewerule","registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null},"deleted":false},"metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":15},"postTime":"2025-04-29T06:03:44.128-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2025-04-29T06:03:44.128-07:00","readOnly":false},"Conversation:conversation:341020":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:341020","topic":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","uid":341020},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2025-04-28T18:42:14.466-07:00","solved":true},"ForumTopicMessage:message:341020":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","subject":"In F5 APM, how to include multiple DNS suffix?","conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:341020"},"id":"message:341020","revisionNum":1,"uid":341020,"depth":0,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"author":{"__typename":"User","uid":435390,"login":"felixk","registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null},"deleted":false},"metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":30},"postTime":"2025-04-27T23:29:12.883-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2025-04-27T23:29:12.883-07:00","readOnly":false},"Conversation:conversation:335741":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:335741","topic":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","uid":335741},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2025-04-28T12:01:53.717-07:00","solved":false},"ForumTopicMessage:message:335741":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","subject":"Issue while migrating config from 4000s to r4600","conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:335741"},"id":"message:335741","revisionNum":1,"uid":335741,"depth":0,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"author":{"__typename":"User","uid":362318,"login":"RahulGupta","registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null},"deleted":false},"metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":171},"postTime":"2024-10-25T12:25:01.297-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2024-10-25T12:25:01.297-07:00","readOnly":false},"Conversation:conversation:341022":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:341022","topic":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","uid":341022},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2025-04-28T02:22:50.076-07:00","solved":false},"ForumTopicMessage:message:341022":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","subject":"Username is not filled in EdgeClient in the Modern customization","conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:341022"},"id":"message:341022","revisionNum":1,"uid":341022,"depth":0,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"author":{"__typename":"User","uid":435746,"login":"francoisbh","registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null},"deleted":false},"metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":22},"postTime":"2025-04-28T02:22:50.076-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2025-04-28T02:22:50.076-07:00","readOnly":false},"Conversation:conversation:341021":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:341021","topic":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","uid":341021},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2025-04-27T23:45:15.969-07:00","solved":false},"ForumTopicMessage:message:341021":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","subject":"Cert Bundle Manager","conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:341021"},"id":"message:341021","revisionNum":1,"uid":341021,"depth":0,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"author":{"__typename":"User","uid":422871,"login":"steven_normole","registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null},"deleted":false},"metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":20},"postTime":"2025-04-27T23:45:15.969-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2025-04-27T23:45:15.969-07:00","readOnly":false},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstMjgtQ3U0RXo2\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstMjgtQ3U0RXo2","height":0,"width":0,"mimeType":"image/svg+xml"},"Rank:rank:28":{"__typename":"Rank","id":"rank:28","position":5,"name":"Employee","color":"C20025","icon":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstMjgtQ3U0RXo2\"}"},"rankStyle":"OUTLINE"},"User:user:216804":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:216804","uid":216804,"login":"Carl_Brothers","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2006-08-23T01:00:00.000-07:00"},"deleted":false,"email":"","avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/dS0yMTY4MDQtRDliNTJh?image-coordinates=0%2C89%2C2400%2C2490"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:28"},"entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:216804"},"ModerationData:moderation_data:202124":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:202124","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null,"isReportedAbuse":false,"rejectUser":null,"rejectTime":null,"rejectActorType":null},"ForumReplyMessage:message:202124":{"__typename":"ForumReplyMessage","author":{"__ref":"User:user:216804"},"id":"message:202124","revisionNum":1,"uid":202124,"depth":1,"hasGivenKudo":false,"subscribed":false,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"parent":{"__ref":"ForumTopicMessage:message:202123"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:202123"},"subject":"Re: F5 vs Open Source?","moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:202124"},"body":"About a year and a half ago, the powers that be sent me on a similar mission as they looked at any licensing and other costs that they could reduce. One result of that larger effort is that someone sold the idea of going with mail hosted by a consumer focused company with a large advertising revenue stream.... But I digress.

 

 

Possible, YES. However there is the management and failover which I found to be the most troubling. Admittedly I am not 'nix admin so I do not know of all the tricks that they may have to bring to the table, but a simple concept like an HA pair of servers hosting NGinX had the smart Linux guys I know scratching their heads when I ran scenarios by them. As is the case with most things 'nix, all the configs are via files, so a simple syntax error will halt the entire process. Syncing the config files is also something that will require creative thinking too. Once you build out a FOSS stack, and it will be a stack of different solutions to get all of the features, good luck keeping the Rube Goldbergian system glued together and not ever fouled by a misconfiguration. To pull it off you would need many people on your team to support the solution who are 'nix, application, and networking GURUs, otherwise a novice without a full understanding of the system could mistakenly bring the whole house of cards down. There was a Long debate that Lori M sparked with some FOSS folks not too long ago where you can read their declarations of \"Yes we can!\" but the details of their solution made my head hurt. Oh and forget admin partitions where u let app owners take nodes one and offline, that is now your job. Also forget everything that is done well with the custom ASICs(SSL Termination & Compression come to mind) inherent with the HW ADC solutions.

 

 

 

An ADC solution built on FOSS is not a one stop shop and requires a high degree of expertise to make it all flow nicely. And with the huge chain of software needed, extensive unit testing would be needed before rolling sw updates to the various modules that would be needed to ensure no disruption of services. And at 2 AM when the solution crashes, which of the umpteen modules caused the crash, who can you get support from and get back online without loosing revenue? How tolerant will management be to wait for you to crawl twenty or so different forums for the modules involved and waiting on responses to posts to attempt to fix the issue?

 

 

 

Regards,

 

 

 

CarlB

 

","body@stripHtml({\"removeProcessingText\":false,\"removeSpoilerMarkup\":false,\"removeTocMarkup\":false,\"truncateLength\":200})@stringLength":"203","kudosSumWeight":0,"repliesCount":0,"postTime":"2011-05-27T06:42:26.000-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2011-05-27T06:42:26.000-07:00","metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":846},"visibilityScope":"PUBLIC","placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"isEscalated":null,"solution":false,"entityType":"FORUM_REPLY","eventPath":"category:Forums/community:zihoc95639board:TechnicalForum/message:202123/message:202124","replies":{"__typename":"MessageConnection","pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null},"edges":[]},"attachments":{"__typename":"AttachmentConnection","edges":[],"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"customFields":[]},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstNDAtSjVqcG5P\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstNDAtSjVqcG5P","height":0,"width":0,"mimeType":"image/svg+xml"},"Rank:rank:40":{"__typename":"Rank","id":"rank:40","position":17,"name":"Altostratus","color":"CCCCCC","icon":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstNDAtSjVqcG5P\"}"},"rankStyle":"FILLED"},"User:user:258607":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:258607","uid":258607,"login":"Chris_Miller","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2009-01-22T00:00:00.000-08:00"},"deleted":false,"email":"","avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/dS0yNTg2MDctMTc0NzNpRDE5QjE5RkEwNzM0NzM3RQ"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:40"},"entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:258607"},"ModerationData:moderation_data:202125":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:202125","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null,"isReportedAbuse":false,"rejectUser":null,"rejectTime":null,"rejectActorType":null},"ForumReplyMessage:message:202125":{"__typename":"ForumReplyMessage","author":{"__ref":"User:user:258607"},"id":"message:202125","revisionNum":1,"uid":202125,"depth":1,"hasGivenKudo":false,"subscribed":false,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"parent":{"__ref":"ForumTopicMessage:message:202123"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:202123"},"subject":"Re: F5 vs Open Source?","moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:202125"},"body":"To elaborate on Carl's point a bit, an ADC is one of the most critical components of a network and therefore must be supported. A good ADC lets you do absorb failures in other places inside your network but putting millions of dollars worth of applications and infrastructure behind something open source and free is a bit risky.","body@stripHtml({\"removeProcessingText\":false,\"removeSpoilerMarkup\":false,\"removeTocMarkup\":false,\"truncateLength\":200})@stringLength":"203","kudosSumWeight":0,"repliesCount":0,"postTime":"2011-05-27T09:34:28.000-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2011-05-27T09:34:28.000-07:00","metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":947},"visibilityScope":"PUBLIC","placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"isEscalated":null,"solution":false,"entityType":"FORUM_REPLY","eventPath":"category:Forums/community:zihoc95639board:TechnicalForum/message:202123/message:202125","replies":{"__typename":"MessageConnection","pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null},"edges":[]},"attachments":{"__typename":"AttachmentConnection","edges":[],"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"customFields":[]},"User:user:122812":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:122812","uid":122812,"login":"The_Bhattman","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2005-10-14T01:00:00.000-07:00"},"deleted":false,"email":"","avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/dS0xMjI4MTItMjAzOTFpMDIxQzBFNjNBQkM5QTY5NQ"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:41"},"entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:122812"},"ModerationData:moderation_data:202126":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:202126","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null,"isReportedAbuse":false,"rejectUser":null,"rejectTime":null,"rejectActorType":null},"ForumReplyMessage:message:202126":{"__typename":"ForumReplyMessage","author":{"__ref":"User:user:122812"},"id":"message:202126","revisionNum":1,"uid":202126,"depth":1,"hasGivenKudo":false,"subscribed":false,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"parent":{"__ref":"ForumTopicMessage:message:202123"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:202123"},"subject":"Re: F5 vs Open Source?","moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:202126"},"body":"Hi Brian,

\n

 

There is an excellent article that was written by F5s Lori MacVittie.

\n

 

\n

 

http://devcentral.f5.com/weblogs/macvittie/archive/2009/04/17/dear-slashdot-you-get-what-you-pay-for.aspx

\n

 

\n

 

This topic generated interesting conversations in the community.

\n

 

\n

 

However, ultimately it comes down to 2 important questions (minus the cost)

\n

 

1) How much features you need and not what you want.

\n

 

2) Can your existing support organization support it (Development, Deployment and Support).

\n

 

\n

 

I hope this helps,

\n

 

Bhattman

\n

 

\n

 

 

","body@stripHtml({\"removeProcessingText\":false,\"removeSpoilerMarkup\":false,\"removeTocMarkup\":false,\"truncateLength\":200})@stringLength":"218","kudosSumWeight":0,"repliesCount":0,"postTime":"2011-06-02T17:03:50.000-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2011-06-02T17:03:50.000-07:00","metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":861},"visibilityScope":"PUBLIC","placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"isEscalated":null,"solution":false,"entityType":"FORUM_REPLY","eventPath":"category:Forums/community:zihoc95639board:TechnicalForum/message:202123/message:202126","replies":{"__typename":"MessageConnection","pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null},"edges":[]},"attachments":{"__typename":"AttachmentConnection","edges":[],"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"customFields":[]},"User:user:356372":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:356372","uid":356372,"login":"L4L7_53191","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2007-08-31T01:00:00.000-07:00"},"deleted":false,"email":"","avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/m_assets/avatars/default/avatar-5.svg?time=0"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:41"},"entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:356372"},"ModerationData:moderation_data:202127":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:202127","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null,"isReportedAbuse":false,"rejectUser":null,"rejectTime":null,"rejectActorType":null},"ForumReplyMessage:message:202127":{"__typename":"ForumReplyMessage","author":{"__ref":"User:user:356372"},"id":"message:202127","revisionNum":1,"uid":202127,"depth":1,"hasGivenKudo":false,"subscribed":false,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"parent":{"__ref":"ForumTopicMessage:message:202123"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:202123"},"subject":"Re: F5 vs Open Source?","moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:202127"},"body":"This is my personal philosophy on architecture / ADN design, which I've put into practice in various capacities. At the risk of this sounding like marketing fluff, one of the main ideas is to put an emphasis on a select set of strategic points of control in your network, then leverage the hell out of them. For me, this stack included the following technologies:

\n

 

\n

 

-- BigIP

\n

 

-- Solaris (for Oracle)

\n

 

-- NetApp

\n

 

-- SLES Linux

\n

 

-- The Apache/Tomcat stack

\n

 

-- Commodity x64 servers, horizontally scaled

\n

 

\n

 

Obviously, there are tons of possible variations and valid arguments for/against this stack, but we found that using this simple stack we could address the vast majority of application delivery challenges that the business would toss our way. You can see the strategic points where we focused our capital investment: BigIP, NetApp, and Oracle.

\n

 

\n

 

Why? We found that using these specific technologies allowed us to say yes far more than no to the business owners, my boss(es), our CTO, etc.

\n

 

\n

 

With an open source solution in place at the BigIP layer, I can say with 100% certainty that I would have had to have made significant compromises to our application delivery environment, if not having to say \"no\" to a huge swath of use cases.

\n

 

\n

 

To blatantly rip off Larry Wall's famous quote: BigIP makes easy things easy and difficult things possible. With an open source LB solution this doesn't hold, particularly at scale: e.g., ask an open source solution to handle 1 million concurrent connections, let alone 32 million, or to 65,000 SSL TPS with 2048-bit keys. There are several reasons for this, but suffice it to say that there are (to me, at least) certain workloads and tasks that require purpose-built, high performance, kick-arse stuff. More and more, people are essentially asking for middleware on the wire, a task that BigIP is uniquely suited for.

\n

 

\n

 

Now, FWIW, I love open source and I've bet my career on it in many respects. But for me it's more about the right tool for the right job. F5 has a ton of *really* smart folks dedicated to making their technology do incredible things. It's a good idea to leverage that domain expertise for this type of job.

\n

 

\n

 

Just my $.02 on this interesting thread!

\n

 

\n

 

-- Matt

 

","body@stripHtml({\"removeProcessingText\":false,\"removeSpoilerMarkup\":false,\"removeTocMarkup\":false,\"truncateLength\":200})@stringLength":"203","kudosSumWeight":0,"repliesCount":0,"postTime":"2011-06-21T21:26:55.000-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2011-06-21T21:26:55.000-07:00","metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":808},"visibilityScope":"PUBLIC","placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"isEscalated":null,"solution":false,"entityType":"FORUM_REPLY","eventPath":"category:Forums/community:zihoc95639board:TechnicalForum/message:202123/message:202127","replies":{"__typename":"MessageConnection","pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null},"edges":[]},"attachments":{"__typename":"AttachmentConnection","edges":[],"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"customFields":[]},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstMjktRWl0NU5q\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstMjktRWl0NU5q","height":24,"width":21,"mimeType":"image/png"},"Rank:rank:29":{"__typename":"Rank","id":"rank:29","position":6,"name":"MVP","color":"7CC0EB","icon":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstMjktRWl0NU5q\"}"},"rankStyle":"FILLED"},"User:user:305752":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:305752","uid":305752,"login":"Nikoolayy1","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2019-10-15T01:14:48.000-07:00","confirmEmailStatus":null,"registrationAccessLevel":null,"ssoRegistrationFields":[]},"deleted":false,"email":"","avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/dS0zMDU3NTItd2tMWnln?image-coordinates=3%2C3%2C176%2C176"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:29"},"messagesCount":1334,"kudosGivenCount":836,"kudosReceivedCount":466,"kudosWeight":1,"ssoId":null,"followersCount":null,"solutionsCount":86,"entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:305752"},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi04OC0xOTQ1Nmk4RjgxOUIyQTAyRkFEMjdB\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi04OC0xOTQ1Nmk4RjgxOUIyQTAyRkFEMjdB","mimeType":"image/png"},"TkbTopicMessage:message:328573":{"__typename":"TkbTopicMessage","uid":328573,"subject":"F5 XC vk8s workload with Open Source Nginx","id":"message:328573","revisionNum":7,"repliesCount":1,"author":{"__ref":"User:user:305752"},"depth":0,"hasGivenKudo":false,"helpful":null,"board":{"__ref":"Tkb:board:communityarticles"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:328573"},"contentWorkflow":{"__typename":"ContentWorkflow","state":"PUBLISH","scheduledPublishTime":null,"scheduledTimezone":null,"shortScheduledTimezone":null,"userContext":{"__typename":"MessageWorkflowContext","canSubmitForReview":null,"canEdit":false,"canRecall":null,"canSubmitForPublication":null,"canReturnToAuthor":null,"canPublish":null,"canReturnToReview":null,"canSchedule":false}},"moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:328573"},"teaser@stripHtml({\"removeProcessingText\":false,\"truncateLength\":200})":"","postTime":"2024-03-26T08:07:32.994-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2024-08-26T08:13:13.877-07:00","readOnly":false,"introduction":"The nginx XC Distributed Cloud workload deployment for virtual kubernetes can be used for url regex rewrite, response body rewrite or advanced custom response pages.","metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":412},"placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"entityType":"TKB_ARTICLE","eventPath":"category:CrowdSRC/community:zihoc95639board:communityarticles/message:328573"},"Conversation:conversation:328573":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:328573","solved":false,"topic":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:328573"},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2024-08-26T08:13:13.877-07:00","lastPostTime":"2024-04-25T23:38:50.408-07:00"},"ModerationData:moderation_data:328573":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:328573","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null},"RelatedContentMessage:RelatedContentMessage:328573":{"__typename":"RelatedContentMessage","id":"RelatedContentMessage:328573","relatedMessage":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:328573"}},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi04Ny0xOTQ1NWk4ODNCOUNEMkFDNDZCQjI0\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi04Ny0xOTQ1NWk4ODNCOUNEMkFDNDZCQjI0","mimeType":"image/png"},"TkbTopicMessage:message:328275":{"__typename":"TkbTopicMessage","uid":328275,"subject":"F5 XC vk8s open source nginx deployment on RE","id":"message:328275","revisionNum":3,"repliesCount":3,"author":{"__ref":"User:user:305752"},"depth":0,"hasGivenKudo":false,"helpful":null,"board":{"__ref":"Tkb:board:codeshare"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:328275"},"contentWorkflow":{"__typename":"ContentWorkflow","state":"PUBLISH","scheduledPublishTime":null,"scheduledTimezone":null,"shortScheduledTimezone":null,"userContext":{"__typename":"MessageWorkflowContext","canSubmitForReview":null,"canEdit":false,"canRecall":null,"canSubmitForPublication":null,"canReturnToAuthor":null,"canPublish":null,"canReturnToReview":null,"canSchedule":false}},"moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:328275"},"teaser@stripHtml({\"removeProcessingText\":false,\"truncateLength\":200})":"","postTime":"2024-03-07T16:03:24.347-08:00","lastPublishTime":"2024-08-01T02:48:53.673-07:00","readOnly":false,"introduction":"","metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":198},"placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"entityType":"TKB_ARTICLE","eventPath":"category:CrowdSRC/community:zihoc95639board:codeshare/message:328275"},"Conversation:conversation:328275":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:328275","solved":false,"topic":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:328275"},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2024-10-31T11:51:22.378-07:00","lastPostTime":"2024-10-31T11:51:22.378-07:00"},"ModerationData:moderation_data:328275":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:328275","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null},"RelatedContentMessage:RelatedContentMessage:328275":{"__typename":"RelatedContentMessage","id":"RelatedContentMessage:328275","relatedMessage":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:328275"}},"Rank:rank:27":{"__typename":"Rank","id":"rank:27","position":2,"name":"Ret. Employee","color":"949494","icon":null,"rankStyle":"OUTLINE"},"User:user:171705":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:171705","uid":171705,"login":"Leslie_Hubertus","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2019-05-15T11:49:57.000-07:00","confirmEmailStatus":null,"registrationAccessLevel":null,"ssoRegistrationFields":[]},"deleted":false,"email":"","avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/dS0xNzE3MDUtMTYzODlpRjI3QjA4QzU2NUIxQUQzNA"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:27"},"messagesCount":1019,"kudosGivenCount":1031,"kudosReceivedCount":415,"kudosWeight":1,"ssoId":null,"followersCount":null,"solutionsCount":15,"entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:171705"},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi0zNi02aTlBNjU5MTlBODIzNDE3MDM\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi0zNi02aTlBNjU5MTlBODIzNDE3MDM","mimeType":"image/png"},"TkbTopicMessage:message:323857":{"__typename":"TkbTopicMessage","uid":323857,"subject":"AppWorld 2024 Call For Speakers open","id":"message:323857","revisionNum":2,"repliesCount":0,"author":{"__ref":"User:user:171705"},"depth":0,"hasGivenKudo":false,"helpful":null,"board":{"__ref":"Tkb:board:DevCentralNews"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:323857"},"contentWorkflow":{"__typename":"ContentWorkflow","state":"PUBLISH","scheduledPublishTime":null,"scheduledTimezone":null,"shortScheduledTimezone":null,"userContext":{"__typename":"MessageWorkflowContext","canSubmitForReview":null,"canEdit":false,"canRecall":null,"canSubmitForPublication":null,"canReturnToAuthor":null,"canPublish":null,"canReturnToReview":null,"canSchedule":false}},"moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:323857"},"teaser@stripHtml({\"removeProcessingText\":false,\"truncateLength\":200})":"","postTime":"2023-11-08T11:32:35.537-08:00","lastPublishTime":"2023-11-29T08:34:52.125-08:00","readOnly":false,"introduction":"","metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":1706},"placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"entityType":"TKB_ARTICLE","eventPath":"category:Articles/community:zihoc95639board:DevCentralNews/message:323857"},"Conversation:conversation:323857":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:323857","solved":false,"topic":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:323857"},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2023-11-29T08:34:52.125-08:00","lastPostTime":"2023-11-08T11:32:35.537-08:00"},"ModerationData:moderation_data:323857":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:323857","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null},"RelatedContentMessage:RelatedContentMessage:323857":{"__typename":"RelatedContentMessage","id":"RelatedContentMessage:323857","relatedMessage":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:323857"}},"User:user:426356":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:426356","uid":426356,"login":"oldbone_proxy","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2023-11-29T06:37:49.236-08:00","confirmEmailStatus":null,"registrationAccessLevel":null,"ssoRegistrationFields":[]},"deleted":false,"email":"","avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/m_assets/avatars/default/avatar-8.svg?time=0"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:40"},"messagesCount":4,"kudosGivenCount":2,"kudosReceivedCount":0,"kudosWeight":1,"ssoId":null,"followersCount":null,"solutionsCount":0,"entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:426356"},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi0zMS0yaUY5MjM3RDI3NzVEQzI1M0U\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bi0zMS0yaUY5MjM3RDI3NzVEQzI1M0U","mimeType":"image/png"},"ForumTopicMessage:message:324835":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","uid":324835,"subject":"How to ensure source address and source port are accepted and traversed properly via F5 SNAT automap","id":"message:324835","revisionNum":3,"repliesCount":5,"author":{"__ref":"User:user:426356"},"depth":0,"hasGivenKudo":false,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:324835"},"moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:324835"},"postTime":"2023-11-29T06:58:26.884-08:00","lastPublishTime":"2023-11-29T07:51:25.170-08:00","readOnly":false,"metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":1769},"placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"isEscalated":null,"entityType":"FORUM_TOPIC","eventPath":"category:Forums/community:zihoc95639board:TechnicalForum/message:324835"},"Conversation:conversation:324835":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:324835","solved":true,"topic":{"__ref":"ForumTopicMessage:message:324835"},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2023-12-01T12:10:53.151-08:00","lastPostTime":"2023-12-01T12:10:53.151-08:00"},"ModerationData:moderation_data:324835":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:324835","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null},"RelatedContentMessage:RelatedContentMessage:324835":{"__typename":"RelatedContentMessage","id":"RelatedContentMessage:324835","relatedMessage":{"__ref":"ForumTopicMessage:message:324835"}},"User:user:318035":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:318035","uid":318035,"login":"OM","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2010-03-08T00:00:00.000-08:00","confirmEmailStatus":null,"registrationAccessLevel":null,"ssoRegistrationFields":[]},"deleted":false,"email":"","avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/m_assets/avatars/default/avatar-1.svg?time=0"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:41"},"messagesCount":86,"kudosGivenCount":1,"kudosReceivedCount":0,"kudosWeight":1,"ssoId":null,"followersCount":null,"solutionsCount":0,"entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:318035"},"ForumTopicMessage:message:329400":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","uid":329400,"subject":"Open Redirection Mitigation","id":"message:329400","revisionNum":1,"repliesCount":6,"author":{"__ref":"User:user:318035"},"depth":0,"hasGivenKudo":false,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:329400"},"moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:329400"},"postTime":"2024-04-26T12:31:41.322-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2024-04-26T12:31:41.322-07:00","readOnly":false,"metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":186},"placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"isEscalated":null,"entityType":"FORUM_TOPIC","eventPath":"category:Forums/community:zihoc95639board:TechnicalForum/message:329400"},"Conversation:conversation:329400":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:329400","solved":true,"topic":{"__ref":"ForumTopicMessage:message:329400"},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2024-05-03T06:40:55.462-07:00","lastPostTime":"2024-05-03T06:40:55.462-07:00"},"ModerationData:moderation_data:329400":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:329400","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null},"RelatedContentMessage:RelatedContentMessage:329400":{"__typename":"RelatedContentMessage","id":"RelatedContentMessage:329400","relatedMessage":{"__ref":"ForumTopicMessage:message:329400"}},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/community/Navbar-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/community/Navbar-1745595729370","value":{"community":"Community Home","inbox":"Inbox","manageContent":"Manage Content","tos":"Terms of Service","forgotPassword":"Forgot Password","themeEditor":"Theme Editor","edit":"Edit Navigation Bar","skipContent":"Skip to content","migrated-link-9":"Groups","migrated-link-7":"Technical Articles","migrated-link-8":"DevCentral News","migrated-link-1":"Technical Forum","migrated-link-10":"Community Groups","migrated-link-2":"Water Cooler","migrated-link-11":"F5 Groups","Common-external-link":"How Do I...?","migrated-link-0":"Forums","article-series":"Article Series","migrated-link-5":"Community Articles","migrated-link-6":"Articles","security-insights":"Security Insights","migrated-link-3":"CrowdSRC","migrated-link-4":"CodeShare","migrated-link-12":"Events","migrated-link-13":"Suggestions"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/community/NavbarHamburgerDropdown-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/community/NavbarHamburgerDropdown-1745595729370","value":{"hamburgerLabel":"Side Menu"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/community/BrandLogo-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/community/BrandLogo-1745595729370","value":{"logoAlt":"Khoros","themeLogoAlt":"Brand Logo"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/community/NavbarTextLinks-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/community/NavbarTextLinks-1745595729370","value":{"more":"More"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/authentication/AuthenticationLink-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/authentication/AuthenticationLink-1745595729370","value":{"title.login":"Sign In","title.registration":"Register","title.forgotPassword":"Forgot Password","title.multiAuthLogin":"Sign In"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/nodes/NodeLink-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/nodes/NodeLink-1745595729370","value":{"place":"Place {name}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/EscalatedMessageBanner-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/EscalatedMessageBanner-1745595729370","value":{"escalationMessage":"Escalated to Salesforce by {username} on {date}","viewDetails":"View Details","modalTitle":"Case Details","escalatedBy":"Escalated by: ","escalatedOn":"Escalated on: ","caseNumber":"Case Number: ","status":"Status: ","lastUpdateDate":"Last Update: ","automaticEscalation":"automatic escalation","anonymous":"Anonymous"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/users/UserLink-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/users/UserLink-1745595729370","value":{"authorName":"View Profile: {author}","anonymous":"Anonymous"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/users/UserRank-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/users/UserRank-1745595729370","value":{"rankName":"{rankName}","userRank":"Author rank {rankName}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageTime-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageTime-1745595729370","value":{"postTime":"Published: {time}","lastPublishTime":"Last Update: {time}","conversation.lastPostingActivityTime":"Last posting activity time: {time}","conversation.lastPostTime":"Last post time: {time}","moderationData.rejectTime":"Rejected time: {time}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageSolvedBadge-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageSolvedBadge-1745595729370","value":{"solved":"Solved"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageSubject-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageSubject-1745595729370","value":{"noSubject":"(no subject)"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageBody-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageBody-1745595729370","value":{"showMessageBody":"Show More","mentionsErrorTitle":"{mentionsType, select, board {Board} user {User} message {Message} other {}} No Longer Available","mentionsErrorMessage":"The {mentionsType} you are trying to view has been removed from the community.","videoProcessing":"Video is being processed. Please try again in a few minutes.","bannerTitle":"Video provider requires cookies to play the video. Accept to continue or {url} it directly on the provider's site.","buttonTitle":"Accept","urlText":"watch"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageCustomFields-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageCustomFields-1745595729370","value":{"CustomField.default.label":"Value of {name}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/common/QueryHandler-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/common/QueryHandler-1745595729370","value":{"title":"Query Handler"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageReplyButton-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageReplyButton-1745595729370","value":{"repliesCount":"{count}","title":"Reply","title@board:BLOG@message:root":"Comment","title@board:TKB@message:root":"Comment","title@board:IDEA@message:root":"Comment","title@board:OCCASION@message:root":"Comment"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/featured/content/AddFeaturedContentModal-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/featured/content/AddFeaturedContentModal-1745595729370","value":{"header":"Edit Featured Content","header.description":"Add, remove, or reorder featured content in this widget{nodeType, select, community{} other{ for {nodeTitle}}}.","PageEditor.header":"Edit Sample Content","PageEditor.header.description":"Add, remove, or reorder sample content to preview how your widget will look.\n\nChanges to sample content here will not be saved or published to any page templates.","AddFeaturedContentModal.selectedMessage.label":"Content","AddFeaturedContentModal.selectedMessage.placeholder":"Find content or enter URL","AddFeaturedContentModal.submit":"Save","AddFeaturedContentModal.cancel":"Cancel","AddFeaturedContentModal.selectedMessage.validate.error":"Select a message","AddFeaturedContentModal.selectedMessage.validate.messageLimitCheck.error":"You can feature up to {limit} posts","submitBtn":"Save","previewBtn":"Preview","cancelBtn":"Cancel","failureTitle":"Error - Action Failed","failureMessage":"An unidentified problem occurred while saving featured content. Please try again later.","successTitle":"Success","successMessage":"Widget updated"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/featured/content/FeaturedContentMessageList-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/featured/content/FeaturedContentMessageList-1745595729370","value":{"edit":"Edit Featured Content","header":"Featured Content"},"localOverride":false},"User:user:419489":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:419489","uid":419489,"login":"HeidiSchreifels","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2022-07-15T10:09:37.046-07:00","confirmEmailStatus":null,"registrationAccessLevel":null,"ssoRegistrationFields":[]},"deleted":false,"email":"","avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/dS00MTk0ODktYU5jVHhK?image-coordinates=0%2C0%2C121%2C120"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:28"},"messagesCount":22,"kudosGivenCount":28,"kudosReceivedCount":30,"kudosWeight":1,"ssoId":null,"followersCount":null,"solutionsCount":1,"entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:419489"},"TkbTopicMessage:message:340911":{"__typename":"TkbTopicMessage","uid":340911,"subject":"The New F5 Certified BIG-IP Administrator Certification Exams Now Live","id":"message:340911","revisionNum":3,"repliesCount":7,"author":{"__ref":"User:user:419489"},"depth":0,"hasGivenKudo":false,"helpful":null,"board":{"__ref":"Tkb:board:DevCentralNews"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:340911"},"contentWorkflow":{"__typename":"ContentWorkflow","state":"PUBLISH","scheduledPublishTime":null,"scheduledTimezone":null,"shortScheduledTimezone":null,"userContext":{"__typename":"MessageWorkflowContext","canSubmitForReview":null,"canEdit":false,"canRecall":null,"canSubmitForPublication":null,"canReturnToAuthor":null,"canPublish":null,"canReturnToReview":null,"canSchedule":false}},"moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:340911"},"teaser":"\n

The F5 Certification is excited to announce that all five of the NEW F5 Certified BIG-IP Administrator Certification (F5 CAB) exams are now live and available to schedule via the new Education Services Portal.

","postTime":"2025-04-23T11:16:38.997-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2025-04-25T10:49:39.663-07:00","images":{"__typename":"AssociatedImageConnection","edges":[{"__typename":"AssociatedImageEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8b3wyNXxfTlZffDE","node":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bS0zNDA5MTEtOEo4VzQw?revision=3\"}"}}],"totalCount":1,"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"tags":{"__typename":"TagConnection","pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":true,"endCursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98NQ","hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null},"edges":[{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98MQ","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:101","text":"101","time":"2022-01-24T02:30:16.258-08:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}},{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98Mg","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:201","text":"201","time":"2022-01-24T02:33:36.625-08:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}},{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98Mw","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:administrator","text":"administrator","time":"2024-04-19T00:36:27.334-07:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}},{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98NA","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:announcement","text":"announcement","time":"2021-12-19T07:45:21.000-08:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}},{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98NQ","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:BIG-IP","text":"BIG-IP","time":"2022-01-24T02:29:45.031-08:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}}]},"timeToRead":3,"introduction":"","metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":186},"placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"videos":{"__typename":"VideoConnection","edges":[],"totalCount":0,"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"entityType":"TKB_ARTICLE","eventPath":"category:Articles/community:zihoc95639board:DevCentralNews/message:340911"},"Conversation:conversation:340911":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:340911","solved":false,"topic":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:340911"},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2025-04-28T08:13:10.869-07:00","lastPostTime":"2025-04-28T08:13:10.869-07:00"},"ModerationData:moderation_data:340911":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:340911","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bS0zNDA5MTEtOEo4VzQw?revision=3\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bS0zNDA5MTEtOEo4VzQw?revision=3","title":"clipboard_image-1-1745603317979.png","associationType":"TEASER","width":610,"height":343,"altText":""},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstMS01bkFrOTY\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstMS01bkFrOTY","height":0,"width":0,"mimeType":"image/svg+xml"},"Rank:rank:1":{"__typename":"Rank","id":"rank:1","position":0,"name":"Admin","color":"C20025","icon":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/cmstMS01bkFrOTY\"}"},"rankStyle":"FILLED"},"User:user:354995":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:354995","uid":354995,"login":"Rebecca_Moloney","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2019-05-30T13:15:33.000-07:00","confirmEmailStatus":null,"registrationAccessLevel":null,"ssoRegistrationFields":[]},"deleted":false,"email":"","avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/dS0zNTQ5OTUtTW1jMnNa?image-coordinates=38%2C357%2C711%2C1029"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:1"},"messagesCount":115,"kudosGivenCount":202,"kudosReceivedCount":165,"kudosWeight":1,"ssoId":null,"followersCount":null,"solutionsCount":2,"entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:354995"},"TkbTopicMessage:message:340701":{"__typename":"TkbTopicMessage","uid":340701,"subject":"F5 Academies Are Back – And We’re Coming to a City Near You","id":"message:340701","revisionNum":12,"repliesCount":1,"author":{"__ref":"User:user:354995"},"depth":0,"hasGivenKudo":false,"helpful":null,"board":{"__ref":"Tkb:board:DevCentralNews"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:340701"},"contentWorkflow":{"__typename":"ContentWorkflow","state":"PUBLISH","scheduledPublishTime":null,"scheduledTimezone":null,"shortScheduledTimezone":null,"userContext":{"__typename":"MessageWorkflowContext","canSubmitForReview":null,"canEdit":false,"canRecall":null,"canSubmitForPublication":null,"canReturnToAuthor":null,"canPublish":null,"canReturnToReview":null,"canSchedule":false}},"moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:340701"},"teaser":"

The F5 Academy Roadshow is rolling into 19 cities (plus two virtual stops), and if you work with apps, APIs, or infrastructure, this event was built for you.

\n\n

 

","postTime":"2025-04-14T09:49:34.463-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2025-04-17T10:30:41.891-07:00","images":{"__typename":"AssociatedImageConnection","edges":[{"__typename":"AssociatedImageEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8b3wyNXxfTlZffDE","node":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bS0zNDA3MDEtblAzc2RQ?revision=12\"}"}}],"totalCount":1,"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"tags":{"__typename":"TagConnection","pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null},"edges":[{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuM3wyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98MQ","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:announcement","text":"announcement","time":"2021-12-19T07:45:21.000-08:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}}]},"timeToRead":3,"introduction":"","metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":245},"placeholder":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"videos":{"__typename":"VideoConnection","edges":[],"totalCount":0,"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"entityType":"TKB_ARTICLE","eventPath":"category:Articles/community:zihoc95639board:DevCentralNews/message:340701"},"Conversation:conversation:340701":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:340701","solved":false,"topic":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:340701"},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2025-04-25T19:01:16.494-07:00","lastPostTime":"2025-04-25T19:01:16.494-07:00"},"ModerationData:moderation_data:340701":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:340701","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bS0zNDA3MDEtblAzc2RQ?revision=12\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bS0zNDA3MDEtblAzc2RQ?revision=12","title":"Academies.jpg","associationType":"TEASER","width":1130,"height":703,"altText":""},"User:user:7":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:7","login":"LiefZimmerman"},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/community/NavbarDropdownToggle-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/community/NavbarDropdownToggle-1745595729370","value":{"ariaLabelClosed":"Press the down arrow to open the menu"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/users/UserAvatar-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/users/UserAvatar-1745595729370","value":{"altText":"{login}'s avatar","altTextGeneric":"User's avatar"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/ranks/UserRankLabel-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/ranks/UserRankLabel-1745595729370","value":{"altTitle":"Icon for {rankName} rank"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/tags/TagView/TagViewChip-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/tags/TagView/TagViewChip-1745595729370","value":{"tagLabelName":"Tag name {tagName}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageListMenu-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageListMenu-1745595729370","value":{"postTimeAsc":"Oldest","postTimeDesc":"Newest","kudosSumWeightAsc":"Least Liked","kudosSumWeightDesc":"Most Liked","sortTitle":"Sort By","sortedBy.item":" { itemName, select, postTimeAsc {Oldest} postTimeDesc {Newest} kudosSumWeightAsc {Least Liked} kudosSumWeightDesc {Most Liked} other {}}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/AcceptedSolutionButton-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/AcceptedSolutionButton-1745595729370","value":{"accept":"Mark as Solution","accepted":"Marked as Solution","errorHeader":"Error!","errorAdd":"There was an error marking as solution.","errorRemove":"There was an error unmarking as solution.","solved":"Solved","topicAlreadySolvedErrorTitle":"Solution Already Exists","topicAlreadySolvedErrorDesc":"Refresh the browser to view the existing solution"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewCard-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewCard-1745595729370","value":{"gotoParent":"Go to parent {name}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewInline-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewInline-1745595729370","value":{"bylineAuthor":"{bylineAuthor}","bylineBoard":"{bylineBoard}","anonymous":"Anonymous","place":"Place {bylineBoard}","gotoParent":"Go to parent {name}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/common/Pager/PagerLoadMore-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/common/Pager/PagerLoadMore-1745595729370","value":{"loadMore":"Show More"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/customComponent/CustomComponent-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/customComponent/CustomComponent-1745595729370","value":{"errorMessage":"Error rendering component id: {customComponentId}","bannerTitle":"Video provider requires cookies to play the video. Accept to continue or {url} it directly on the provider's site.","buttonTitle":"Accept","urlText":"watch"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/nodes/NodeIcon-1745595729370":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/nodes/NodeIcon-1745595729370","value":{"contentType":"Content Type {style, select, FORUM {Forum} BLOG {Blog} TKB {Knowledge Base} IDEA {Ideas} OCCASION {Events} other {}} icon"},"localOverride":false}}}},"page":"/forums/ForumMessagePage/ForumMessagePage","query":{"boardId":"technicalforum","messageSubject":"f5-vs-open-source","messageId":"202123"},"buildId":"ISAhs0UxT148eG089lpQq","runtimeConfig":{"buildInformationVisible":false,"logLevelApp":"info","logLevelMetrics":"info","openTelemetryClientEnabled":false,"openTelemetryConfigName":"f5","openTelemetryServiceVersion":"25.3.0","openTelemetryUniverse":"prod","openTelemetryCollector":"http://localhost:4318","openTelemetryRouteChangeAllowedTime":"5000","apolloDevToolsEnabled":false,"inboxMuteWipFeatureEnabled":false},"isFallback":false,"isExperimentalCompile":false,"dynamicIds":["./components/seo/QAPageSchema/QAPageSchema.tsx","./components/customComponent/CustomComponent/CustomComponent.tsx","./components/community/Navbar/NavbarWidget.tsx","./components/community/Breadcrumb/BreadcrumbWidget.tsx","./components/messages/TopicWithThreadedReplyListWidget/TopicWithThreadedReplyListWidget.tsx","./components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewStandard/MessageViewStandard.tsx","./components/messages/ThreadedReplyList/ThreadedReplyList.tsx","./components/featured/content/FeaturedContentWidget/FeaturedContentWidget.tsx","./components/messages/MessageListForNodeByRecentActivityWidget/MessageListForNodeByRecentActivityWidget.tsx","./components/messages/RelatedContentWidget/RelatedContentWidget.tsx","./components/featured/content/AddFeaturedContentModal/AddFeaturedContentModal.tsx","./components/customComponent/CustomComponentContent/TemplateContent.tsx","../shared/client/components/common/List/UnwrappedList/UnwrappedList.tsx","./components/tags/TagView/TagView.tsx","./components/tags/TagView/TagViewChip/TagViewChip.tsx","../shared/client/components/common/List/UnstyledList/UnstyledList.tsx","./components/messages/MessageView/MessageView.tsx","../shared/client/components/common/List/GridList/GridList.tsx","./components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewCard/MessageViewCard.tsx","./components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewInline/MessageViewInline.tsx","../shared/client/components/common/Pager/PagerLoadMore/PagerLoadMore.tsx","./components/customComponent/CustomComponentContent/HtmlContent.tsx","./components/customComponent/CustomComponentContent/CustomComponentScripts.tsx"],"appGip":true,"scriptLoader":[]}