Forum Discussion

statmp_87631's avatar
statmp_87631
Icon for Nimbostratus rankNimbostratus
Dec 19, 2011

iRules with subnet failed.

Hi,I met a problem with iRules recently, below is our iRules:

 

 

 

if { [IP::addr [IP::remote_addr] equals 221.177.152.0/26] } {

 

 

 

pool CMNET }

 

 

 

else { pool CMWAP_ OTHER }}

 

 

 

if the DNS query client with IP address 221.177.152.33 send a DNS message, f5 will answer with pool CMWAP_OTHER.

 

 

 

 

 

and if we change the iRules to below, the answer will be correct with pool CMNET.

 

if { [IP::addr [IP::remote_addr] equals 221.177.152.33/32] } {

 

pool CMNET }

 

else {

 

pool CMWAP_ OTHER

 

}

 

}

 

 

 

so , what's the difference between a host and a subnet int iRules?

 

thanks

 

 

 

 

 

 

application delivery
dev
devops
iRules
  • harry_35316's avatar
    harry_35316
    Icon for Nimbostratus rankNimbostratus
    Dec 19, 2011
    I dont think we can use the euqals command for the IP range subnet...Try with using the below if statement. This may not be correct but i think we cannot use equals for a range of IPs since the equals to operator checks for the exact match only...

     

    if{ [221.177.152.0< IP::addr[IP::remote_addr] ] & [IP::addr[IP::remote_addr]<=221.177.152.63]}{

     

    pool CMNET

     

    }

     

    else..
  • statmp_87631's avatar
    statmp_87631
    Icon for Nimbostratus rankNimbostratus
    Dec 19, 2011
    good idear!!!

     

     

    but, below sentence was copied from DevCentral Wiki, the descripion of IP::addr:

     

     

    To perform comparison of client-side IP address with subnet 10.0.0.0. (Will return 1 or 0, depending on client IP address.)

     

     

    view sourceprint?1 [IP::addr [IP::client_addr] equals 10.0.0.0/8]
  • statmp_87631's avatar
    statmp_87631
    Icon for Nimbostratus rankNimbostratus
    Dec 19, 2011
    got wrong message with operator "<"

     

    line 2: [undefined procedure: 221.177.152.0] [221.177.152.0 < IP::addr [ IP::remote_addr ] ]

     

    line 2: [invalid option "<" must be: equals mask parse] [IP::addr [ IP::remote_addr ] < 221.177.152.63 ]

     

     

    seems the only opreator is "equals"

     

    Syntax¶

     

    1 IP::addr [/] equals [/]

     

    2 IP::addr parse [-swap] []

     

    3

     

    4 v11 Additions/Changes:

     

    5 IP::addr parse [-ipv6|-ipv4 [-swap]] []
  • nitass's avatar
    nitass
    Icon for Employee rankEmployee
    Dec 19, 2011
    IP::addr [IP::remote_addr] equals 221.177.152.0/26 should be correct.

     

     

    how do you know if traffic is sent to wrong pool? can you make some log in event such as SERVER_CONNECTED?
  • statmp_87631's avatar
    statmp_87631
    Icon for Nimbostratus rankNimbostratus
    Dec 19, 2011
    my device is GTM 3900, and I can use "nslookup" to check the DNS query answer results from different pools.

     

     

    this means different pools return different DNS answers.

     

     

    In my case, IP::addr [IP::remote_addr] equals 221.177.152.0/26 will never match the DNS query host IP address, but 221.177.152.33/32 will be correct, do I need some licence or have some special settings in the system?
  • statmp_87631's avatar
    statmp_87631
    Icon for Nimbostratus rankNimbostratus
    Dec 19, 2011
    my device is GTM 3900, and I can use "nslookup" to check the DNS query answer results from different pools.

     

     

    this means different pools return different DNS answers.

     

     

    In my case, IP::addr [IP::remote_addr] equals 221.177.152.0/26 will never match the DNS query host IP address, but 221.177.152.33/32 will be correct, do I need some licence or have some special settings in the system?
  • hooleylist's avatar
    hooleylist
    Icon for Cirrostratus rankCirrostratus
    Dec 19, 2011
    You don't need to use /32 as it's implicit when you use a host address with IP::addr:

     

     

    if { [IP::addr [IP::remote_addr] equals 221.177.152.33] } {

     

     

    Aaron
  • statmp_87631's avatar
    statmp_87631
    Icon for Nimbostratus rankNimbostratus
    Dec 19, 2011
    now the problem is:

     

    1. [IP::addr [IP::remote_addr] equals 221.177.152.33/32] works fine.

     

    2. [IP::addr [IP::remote_addr] equals 221.177.152.0/26] never match the source clients.
  • hooleylist's avatar
    hooleylist
    Icon for Cirrostratus rankCirrostratus
    Dec 19, 2011
    221.177.152.0/26 should match 221.177.152.0 - 221.177.152.63. Can you try logging the client IP to verify what you're getting for [IP::remote_addr]?

    Here's a v11 rule you can use to confirm this: 

    
when RULE_INIT {
for {set i 0}{$i <=63}{incr i}{
log local0. "\[IP::addr 221.177.152.$i equals 221.177.152.0/26\]: [IP::addr 221.177.152.$i equals 221.177.152.0/26]"
}
}

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.0 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.1 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.2 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.3 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.4 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.5 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.6 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.7 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.8 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.9 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.10 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.11 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.12 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.13 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.14 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.15 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.16 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.17 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.18 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.19 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.20 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.21 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.22 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.23 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.24 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.25 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.26 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.27 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.28 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.29 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.30 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.31 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.32 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.33 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.34 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.35 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.36 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.37 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.38 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.39 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.40 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.41 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.42 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.43 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.44 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.45 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.46 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.47 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.48 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.49 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.50 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.51 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.52 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.53 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.54 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.55 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.56 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.57 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.58 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.59 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.60 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.61 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.62 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    [IP::addr 221.177.152.63 equals 221.177.152.0/26]: 1

    Aaron
  • statmp_87631's avatar
    statmp_87631
    Icon for Nimbostratus rankNimbostratus
    Dec 20, 2011
    Thanks for your kindly support.

     

    here is my iRules:

     

    when DNS_REQUEST {

     

    if { [IP::addr [IP::remote_addr] equals 10.97.188.0/24] } {

     

    log local0. "[IP::remote_addr] equals 10.97.188.0/24 Correct!!!! : [IP::addr [IP::remote_addr] equals 10.97.188.0/24]"

     

    }

     

    else {

     

    log local0. "[IP::remote_addr] equals 10.97.188.0/24 Error!!!!! : [IP::addr [IP::remote_addr] equals 10.97.188.0/24]"

     

    }

     

    }

     

     

     

    and got log with ERROR:

     

    Rule HN_GGSN_Pool_rules: 10.97.188.124 equals 10.97.188.0/24 Error!!!!! : 0

     

     

    this can make sure [IP::addr 10.97.188.124 equals 10.97.188.0/24] returns 0, that's joke?