Forum Discussion

TimRiker's avatar
TimRiker
Icon for Cirrocumulus rankCirrocumulus
Dec 13, 2022

APM LDAP by path

I'm trying to figure out a means to allow different LDAP query limits for different paths on the same server. https://example.com/italyonly/ - co=it https://example.com/groupFoo/ user in in group=...
devops
security
TimRiker's avatar
TimRiker
Icon for Cirrocumulus rankCirrocumulus

That looks exactly like what I want, but unfortunately it does not seem to work.

Is there anything else I need to do? With this changed and saved, restarted tmm, failed over to another node, failed back, db entry is "disabled" as shown:

tmsh list sys db apm.ldap.autoescape one-line
sys db apm.ldap.autoescape { value "disable" }

And SearchFilter set to something like:

(&(cn=%{session.oauth.client.last.id_token.cn})(%{session.ldapsearch}))

I still get errors like:

2022-12-13T20:33:35.393-07:00 xxxx warning apmd[8859]: 01490233:4: /Common/access_xxxx:Common:895b427c: LDAP Module: Cannot find any object in search DN 'ou=people,o=org' matching filter '(&(cn=something)(field=\2a))'

when session.ldapsearch = "field=*"

Running BIG-IP 15.1.5.1

Lucas_Thompson's avatar
Lucas_Thompson
Icon for Employee rankEmployee
Dec 14, 2022

Shoot. Sorry I misunderstood the internal writeup on this. Instead of not escaping itself it looks like it expects *you* to escape it manually. Can you try setting it to "\66\69\65\6C\64\3D\2A"? That should be "field=*". 

You're going to have to double-escape them inside the iRule or policy agent config. TCL gets weird with escaping sometimes. The example I've got from bigip.conf where the variable is being set from a var-assign policy agent to "medusademo" to formulate a search filter is:

apm policy agent variable-assign /Common/ldaptest_act_variable_assign_ag {
    variables {
        {
            expression "expr { \"\\\\59\\\\87\\\\FB\\\\A6\\\\AB\\\\1E\\\\D7\\\\40\\\\BE\\\\F8\\\\C7\\\\66\\\\C7\\\\DE\\\\CD\\\\56\" }"
            varname session.objectguid.foo
        }
    }
}

apm policy agent aaa-ldap /Common/ldap_query_bar_act_ldap_query_ag {
    filter "objectGUID=%{session.objectguid.foo}"
    search-dn cn=users,dc=lab,dc=apm,dc=f5test,dc=local
    server /Common/ldapQATest4
    type query
}

 If it doesn't work at first, packet capture a plaintext LDAP query so you can see what it's sending on the wire, the escaping might not be exactly right.

  • TimRiker's avatar
    TimRiker
    Icon for Cirrocumulus rankCirrocumulus
    Dec 14, 2022

    I added this in my iRule.

    ACCESS::session data set session.ldapsearch "\\66\\69\\65\\6C\\64\\3D\\2A"
catch {log local0. "sls=[ACCESS::session data get session.ldapsearch]"}

    Output:

    2022-12-14T11:20:24.600-07:00 <f5> info tmm1[12587]: Rule /Common/<vip> <ACCESS_POLICY_AGENT_EVENT>: sls=\66\69\65\6C\64\3D\2A

    however, I get this:

    2022-12-14T11:20:25.517-07:00 <f5> err apmd[5091]: 01490235:3: /Common/<access policy>:Common:6c31ab75: LDAP Module: Failed to make ldap_search in '<search dn>' with filter '(&(<user filter>)(\5c66\5c69\5c65\5c6C\5c64\5c3D\5c2A))' and scope '2'. Bad search filter.

    The entries in <> are redacted. The "\5c66\5c69\5c65\5c6C\5c64\5c3D\5c2A" here is the search, which, as you can see, is still expanded from "\66\69\65\6C\64\3D\2A". So escaping it in the iRule and session variable, means it gets double-escaped in the ldap search.

    I rebooted the F5 and failed it back to primary before running this test. The db entry is still set:

    # tmsh list sys db apm.ldap.autoescape one-line
sys db apm.ldap.autoescape { value "disable" }

    redacted details:

    # tmsh list apm policy agent aaa-ldap /Common/<policy>_act_ldap_query_ag
apm policy agent aaa-ldap <policy>_act_ldap_query_ag {
    filter "(&(<id>=%{session.oauth.client.last.id_token.<idname>})(%{session.ldapsearch}))"
    search-dn <searchdn>
    server <ldap>
    show-extended-error true
    type query
}

     Thoughts?

    • TimRiker's avatar
      TimRiker
      Icon for Cirrocumulus rankCirrocumulus
      Dec 14, 2022

      Putting the entire search in via the irule and setting SearchFilter to %{session.ldapsearch} also gets escaped. Using this set:

      ACCESS::session data set session.ldapsearch "(&(<id>=[ACCESS::session data get session.oauth.client.last.id_token.<id name>])(field=*))"
catch {log local0. "sls=[ACCESS::session data get session.ldapsearch]"}

      Logs correctly:

      2022-12-14T11:38:57.390-07:00 <f5> info tmm[12587]: Rule /Common/<rule> <ACCESS_POLICY_AGENT_EVENT>: sls=(&(<id>=<user id>)(field=*))

      Redacted output:

      2022-12-14T11:38:57.400-07:00 <f5> err apmd[5091]: 01490235:3: /Common/<policy>:Common:1bda35bc: LDAP Module: Failed to make ldap_search in '<searchdn>' with filter '\28&\28<id>=<user id>\29\28field=\2a\29\29' and scope '2'. Bad search filter.
  • TimRiker's avatar
    TimRiker
    Icon for Cirrocumulus rankCirrocumulus
    Dec 15, 2022

    If the F5 is not autoescaping, and the entity value has problematic characters in it like "()*|!&:~\" those would break ldap searches, and the user would need to esape those someplace.

    Normally the F5 does RFC-4515 escape strings. This makes sense for entities, but NOT for search filters.

    The db option makes sense, however setting it seems to have no effect for me.