Forum Discussion

PidduckM's avatar
PidduckM
Icon for Nimbostratus rankNimbostratus
Mar 26, 2025
Solved

LTM VS padding payload response with whitespaces and asterisk

I have an application that talks to an old OpenVMS system, which was problematic in permanently closing TCP connections. To resolve this issue, I have put a BIG-IP Virtual Server in between them, so the message flow is now:

webMethods --> BIG-IP LTM --> OpenVMS server

This has resolved the TCP connection issue, and I thought everything was good.

However, the application sends XML, and the VMS system responds with the XML payload.

For some reason, BIG-IP is padding the response with lots whitespaces and one asterisk *

The webMethods server does not expect the * in the response and fails to process the response to the client (who originally sent the XML).

 So why is BIG-IP adding the * to the response payload?

 

I've included a WireShark trace image, which shows the BIG-IP VS 10.1.4.170 responding to the webMethods server 10.1.4.225, with the payload, including lots of HEX 20 (whitespace) and one * at the end.

 

My VS configuration uses Type Standard with all the defaults, except, of course, that I've configured the Destination Address and Service Port (3012) and added a Pool.

 

The closes F5 article I have found is this one:

K44201501: BIG-IP is padding HTTP response with additional whitespaces
https://my.f5.com/manage/s/article/K44201501

However, I don't have Analytics configured on this VS, and I don't have Application Visibility and Reporting (AVR) provisioned. So, this doesn't apply, but it's a similar issue.

 

  • PidduckM's avatar
    PidduckM
    Mar 31, 2025

    Hi zamroni777

    Thanks for your reply.

    My post took a few days to publish, and I was trying to find a way to delete my post.

    A Developer informed me of this issue (padding with many whitespaces and one asterisk ), and I could see the behaviour in the TCPdump. However, when doing a TCPdump on the OpenVMS server and bypassing BIG-IP, I saw the same behaviour, so BIG-IP is not adding this asterisk; it's always been there. I compared the traces, and they were the same, so I was misinformed by the Developer.

    Thanks for taking the time to respond.

     

2 Replies

  • do you have http profile assigned into the vserver?

    and change decoding to HTTP in tcpdump so we can see the http headers and payload.

    • PidduckM's avatar
      PidduckM
      Icon for Nimbostratus rankNimbostratus

      Hi zamroni777

      Thanks for your reply.

      My post took a few days to publish, and I was trying to find a way to delete my post.

      A Developer informed me of this issue (padding with many whitespaces and one asterisk ), and I could see the behaviour in the TCPdump. However, when doing a TCPdump on the OpenVMS server and bypassing BIG-IP, I saw the same behaviour, so BIG-IP is not adding this asterisk; it's always been there. I compared the traces, and they were the same, so I was misinformed by the Developer.

      Thanks for taking the time to respond.