Using Cryptonice to check for HTTPS misconfigurations in devsecops workflows
Co-Author: Katie Newbold, F5 Labs Intern, Summer 2020 A huge thanks to Katie Newbold, lead developer on the Cryptonice project, for her amazing work and patience as I constantly moved the goal posts for this project. ---F5 Labs recently published an article Introducing the Cryptonice HTTPS Scanner. Cryptonice is aimed at making it easy for everyone to scan for and diagnose problems with HTTPS configurations. It is provided as a is a command line tool and Python library that allows a user to examine the TLS protocols and ciphers, certificate information, web application headers and DNS records for one or more supplied domain names. You can read more about why Cryptonice was released over at F5 Labs but it basically boils down a few simple reasons. Primarily, many people fire-and-forget their HTTPS configurations which mean they become out of date, and therefore weak, over time. In addition, other protocols, such as DNS can be used to improve upon the strength of TLS but few sites make use of them. Finally, with an increasing shift to automation (i.e. devsecops) it’s important to integrate TLS testing into the application lifecycle. How do I use Cryptonice? Since the tool is available as an executable, a Python script, and a Python library, there are a number of ways and means in which you might use Cryptonice. For example: The executable may be useful for those that do not have Python 3 installed and who want to perform occasional ad-hoc scans against internal or external websites The Python script may be installed along side other Python tools which could allow an internal security team to perform regular and scriptable scanning of internal sites The Python library could be used within devops automation workflows to check for valid certificates, protocols and ciphers when new code is pushed into dev or production environments The aforementioned F5 Labs article provides a quick overview of how to use the command line executable and Python script. But this is DevCentral, after all, so let’s focus on how to use the Python library in your own code. Using Cryptonice in your own code Cryptonice can output results to the console but, since we’re coding, we’ll focus on the detailed JSON output that it produces. Since it collects all scan and test results into a Python dictionary, this variable can be read directly, or your code may wish to read in the completed JSON output. More on this later. First off we’ll need to install the Cryptonice library. With Python 3 installed, we simply use the pip command to download and install it, along with its dependencies. pip install cryptonice Installing Cryptonice using pip will also install the dependent libraries: cffi, cryptography , dnspython, http-client, ipaddress, nassl, pycurl, pycparser, six, sslyze, tls-parser, and urllib3. You may see a warning about the cryptography library installation if you have a version that is greater than 2.9, but cryptonice will still function. This warning is generated because the sslyze package currently requires the cryptography library version to be between 2.6 and 2.9. Creating a simple Cryptonice script An example script (sample_script.py) is included in the GitHub repository. In this example, the script reads in a fully formatted JSON file called sample_scan.json from the command line (see below) and outputs the results in to a JSON file whose filename is based on the site being scanned. The only Cryptonice module that needs to be imported in this script is scanner. The JSON input is converted to a dictionary object and sent directly to the scanner_driver function, where the output is written to a JSON file through the writeToJSONFile function. from cryptonice import scanner import argparse import json def main(): parser = argparse.ArgumentParser() parser.add_argument("input_file", help="JSON input file of scan commands") args = parser.parse_args() input_file = args.input_file with open(input_file) as f: input_data = json.load(f) output_data, hostname = scanner.scanner_driver(input_data) if output_data is None and hostname is None: print("Error with input - scan was not completed") if __name__ == "__main__": main() In our example, above, the scanner_driver function is being passed the necessary dictionary object which is created from the JSON file being supplied as a command line parameter. Alternatively, the dictionary object could be created dynamically in your own code. It must, however, contain the same key/value pairs as our sample input file, below: This is what the JSON input file must look like: { "id": string, "port": int, "scans": [string] "tls_params":[string], "http_body": boolean, "force_redirect": boolean, "print_out": boolean, "generate_json": boolean, "targets": [string] } If certain parameters (such as “scans”, “tls_parameters”, or “targets”) are excluded completely, the program will abort early and print an error message to the console. Mimicking command line input If you would like to mimic the command line input in your own code, you could write a function that accepts a domain name via command line parameter and runs a suite of scans as defined in your variable default_dict: from cryptonice.scanner import writeToJSONFile, scanner_driver import argparse default_dict = {'id': 'default', 'port': 443, 'scans': ['TLS', 'HTTP', 'HTTP2', 'DNS'], 'tls_params': ["certificate_info", "ssl_2_0_cipher_suites", "ssl_3_0_cipher_suites", "tls_1_0_cipher_suites", "tls_1_1_cipher_suites", "tls_1_2_cipher_suites", "tls_1_3_cipher_suites", "http_headers"], 'http_body': False, 'print_out': True, 'generate_json': True, 'force_redirect': True } def main(): parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(description="Supply commands to cryptonice") parser.add_argument("domain", nargs='+', help="Domain name to scan", type=str) args = parser.parse_args() domain_name = args.domain if not domain_name: parser.error('domain (like www.google.com or f5.com) is required') input_data = default_dict input_data.update({'targets': domain_name}) output_data, hostname = scanner_driver(input_data) if output_data is None and hostname is None: print("Error with input - scan was not completed") if __name__ == "__main__": main() Using the Cryptonice JSON output Full documentation for the Cryptonice JSON output will shortly be available on the Cryptonice ReadTheDocs pages and whilst many of the key/value pairs will be self explanatory, let’s take a look at some of the more useful ones. TLS protocols and ciphers The tls_scan block contains detailed information about the protocols, ciphers and certificates discovered as part of the handshake with the target site. This can be used to check for expired or expiring certificates, to ensure that old protocols (such as SSLv3) are not in use and to view recommendations. cipher_suite_supported shows the cipher suite preferred by the target webserver. This is typically the best (read most secure) one available to modern clients. Similarly, highest_tls_version_supported shows the latest available version of the TLS protocol for this site. In this example, cert_recommendations is blank but is a certificate were untrusted or expired this would be a quick place to check for any urgent action that should be taken. The dns section shows results for cryptographically relevant DNS records, for example Certificate Authority Authorization (CAA) and DKIM (found in the TXT records). In our example, below, we can see a dns_recommendations entry which suggested implementing DNS CAA since no such records can be found for this domain. { "scan_metadata":{ "job_id":"test.py", "hostname":"example.com", "port":443, "node_name":"Cocumba", "http_to_https":true, "status":"Successful", "start":"2020-07-1314:31:09.719227", "end":"2020-07-1314:31:16.939356" }, "http_headers":{ "Connection":{ }, "Headers":{ }, "Cookies":{ } }, "tls_scan":{ "hostname":"example.com", "ip_address":"104.127.16.98", "cipher_suite_supported":"TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384", "client_authorization_requirement":"DISABLED", "highest_tls_version_supported":"TLS_1_3", "cert_recommendations":{ }, "certificate_info":{ "leaf_certificate_has_must_staple_extension":false, "leaf_certificate_is_ev":false, "leaf_certificate_signed_certificate_timestamps_count":3, "leaf_certificate_subject_matches_hostname":true, "ocsp_response":{ "status":"SUCCESSFUL", "type":"BasicOCSPResponse", "version":1, "responder_id":"17D9D6252267F931C24941D93036448C6CA91FEB", "certificate_status":"good", "hash_algorithm":"sha1", "issuer_name_hash":"21F3459A18CAA6C84BDA1E3962B127D8338A7C48", "issuer_key_hash":"37D9D6252767F931C24943D93036448C2CA94FEB", "serial_number":"BB72FE903FA2B374E1D06F9AC9BC69A2" }, "ocsp_response_is_trusted":true, "certificate_0":{ "common_name":"*.example.com", "serial_number":"147833492218452301349329569502825345612", "public_key_algorithm":"RSA", "public_key_size":2048, "valid_from":"2020-01-1700:00:00", "valid_until":"2022-01-1623:59:59", "days_left":552, "signature_algorithm":"sha256", "subject_alt_names":[ "www.example.com" ], "certificate_errors":{ "cert_trusted":true, "hostname_matches":true } } }, "ssl_2_0":{ "preferred_cipher_suite":null, "accepted_ssl_2_0_cipher_suites":[] }, "ssl_3_0":{ "preferred_cipher_suite":null, "accepted_ssl_3_0_cipher_suites":[] }, "tls_1_0":{ "preferred_cipher_suite":null, "accepted_tls_1_0_cipher_suites":[] }, "tls_1_1":{ "preferred_cipher_suite":null, "accepted_tls_1_1_cipher_suites":[] }, "tls_1_2":{ "preferred_cipher_suite":"TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_GCM_SHA384", "accepted_tls_1_2_cipher_suites":[ "TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_CHACHA20_POLY1305_SHA256", "TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_GCM_SHA384", "TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384", "TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA", "TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_128_GCM_SHA256", "TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_128_CBC_SHA256", "TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_128_CBC_SHA" ] }, "tls_1_3":{ "preferred_cipher_suite":"TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384", "accepted_tls_1_3_cipher_suites":[ "TLS_CHACHA20_POLY1305_SHA256", "TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384", "TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256", "TLS_AES_128_CCM_SHA256", "TLS_AES_128_CCM_8_SHA256" ] }, "tests":{ "compression_supported":false, "accepts_early_data":false, "http_headers":{ "strict_transport_security_header":{ "preload":false, "include_subdomains":true, "max_age":15768000 } } }, "scan_information":{ }, "tls_recommendations":{ } }, "dns":{ "Connection":"example.com", "dns_recommendations":{ "Low-CAA":"ConsidercreatingDNSCAArecordstopreventaccidentalormaliciouscertificateissuance." }, "records":{ "A":[ "104.127.16.98" ], "CAA":[], "TXT":[], "MX":[] } }, "http2":{ "http2":false } } Advanced Cryptonice use - Calling specific modules There are 6 files in Cryptonice that are necessary for its functioning in other code. scanner.py and checkport.py live in the Cryptonice folder, and getdns.py, gethttp.py. gethttp2.py and gettls.py all live in the cryptonice/modules folder. A full scan is run out of the scanner_driver function in scanner.py, which generates a dictionary object based on the commands it receives via the input parameter dictionary. scanner_driver is modularized, allowing you to call as many or as few of the modules as needed for your purposes. However, if you would like to customize the use of the cryptonice library further, individual modules can be selected and run as well. You may choose to call the scanner_driver function and have access to all the modules in one location, or you could call on certain modules while excluding others. Here is an example of a function that calls the tls_scan function in modules/gettls.py to specifically make use of the TLS code and none of the other modules. from cryptonice.modules.gettls import tls_scan def tls_info(): ip_address = "172.217.12.196" host = "www.google.com" commands = ["certificate_info"] port = 443 tls_data = tls_scan(ip_address, host, commands, port) cert_0 = tls_data.get("certificate_info").get("certificate_0") # Print certificate information print(f'Common Name:\t\t\t{cert_0.get("common_name")}') print(f'Public Key Algorithm:\t\t{cert_0.get("public_key_algorithm")}') print(f'Public Key Size:\t\t{cert_0.get("public_key_size")}') if cert_0.get("public_key_algorithm") == "EllipticCurvePublicKey": print(f'Curve Algorithm:\t\t{cert_0.get("curve_algorithm")}') print(f'Signature Algorithm:\t\t{cert_0.get("signature_algorithm")}') if __name__ == "__main__": tls_info() Getting Started The modularity of Cryptonice makes it a versatile tool to be used within other projects. Whether you want to use it to test the strength of an internal website using the command line tool or integrate the modules into another project, Cryptonice provides a detailed and easy way to capture certificate information, HTTP headers, DNS restrictions, TLS configuration and more. We plan to add additional modules to query certificate transparency logs, test for protocols such as HTTP/3 and produce detailed output with guidance on how to improve your cryptographics posture on the web. This is version 1.0, and we encourage the submission of bugs and enhancements to our Github page to provide fixes and new features so that everyone may benefit from them. The Cryptonice code and binary releases are maintained on the F5 Labs Github pages. Full documentation is currently being added to our ReadTheDocs page and the Cryptonice library is available on PyPi.: F5 Labs overview: https://www.f5.com/labs/cryptonice Source and releases: https://github.com/F5-Labs/cryptonice PyPi library: https://pypi.org/project/cryptonice Documentation: https://cryptonice.readthedocs.io
Per-Request policy Proxy Select and HTTPS
Hi, I can't see any info about limitation for Proxy Select object in Per-Request Policy (PRP) to only http traffic. It's working without issue for http request and pass them to upstream proxy. For https requests (with SSL Bypass Set before Proxy Select) Connection is never reaching upstream proxy. Instead in PRP log I have entry: Common/explicit_proxy_policy:Common:642030b8: Executed agent (/Common/explicit_complete_bypass_act_proxy_select_ag) failed with reason (UNKNOWN) Any idea why? Piotr
https connection with URI shows as not secured ?
Hi Team , We have a new VIP with url https://example.test.com , but when we try to access the url with uri it says "The information you're bout to submit is not secure " https://example.test.com >> WORKS https://example.test.com/sap/saml2/sp/acs/100 >> error : "The information you're bout to submit is not secure " Please advice .
HTTP Monitor
Hi, I want to set an HTTP monitor with the "Receive String" and the "Receive Disable String" so my application return the below results : {"EXCEPTION":false,"RESULT":"{\"DBUp\":true,\"serverUp\":true}"} ==> app is OK {"EXCEPTION":false,"RESULT":"{\"DBUp\":true,\"serverUp\":false}"} ==> app is not OK {"EXCEPTION":false,"RESULT":"{\"DBUp\":false,\"serverUp\":true}"} ==> app is not OK {"EXCEPTION":false,"RESULT":"{\"DBUp\":false,\"serverUp\":false}"} ==> app is not OK my configuration is : Receive String : (true.*true) Receive Disable String : (DBUp\W{3}false)|(serverUp\W{3}false) but this monitor is not working, any one can help please ? Regards,HTTP to HTTPS redirect over the same port
Hello, i hope you can help me. I need an http to https redirect to the same port. For example I enter the URL http://dev.intern.com:25001 and I want to get redirected to https://dev.intern.com:25001. I tried a second virtual server but this didn't work because the loadbalancer can't have two the same IP and ports for a second server which redirects it with an irule to the https virtual Server which is understandable. Thank you already and best regards!
