CirrusUsing F5 for load balancing internal traffic
irbk That is great that you figured out the solution but I would like to mention a few things so you do not set yourself up for failure.
1. Unless absolutely necessary I would avoid using Auto Map and instead create a snatpool and use the same IP as the Virtual Server you have created and use that snatpool instead of Auto Map. The reason for this is if you find yourself in a situation where you have a virtual server/s that has a significant amount of connections your health monitors and a few other things could stop functioning because you will have exhausted all the ephemeral ports on the F5s self-IP which is what is used for Auto Map.
2. The reason the F5 requires SNAT to be configured for your situation is because when traffic traverses the F5 from one interface to another and that traffic has to pass through the F5 the F5 will automatically stitch the two connections together while allowing the server to see the original client IP. Your configuration for internal is necessary because the client, one of the other devices in the same subnet as the pool members, can be seen by the destination pool members so instead of the pool members responding back through the already formed TCP connection through the F5 they will go directly to the client since they know its IP which breaks the TCP connection previously formed through the F5. With SNAT enabled the pool members only see the F5 as the source of the connection so the pool members have to respond back to the F5 which then allows the F5 to stitch the client side and server side connections together.
3. If you require tracking of the true client in a SNAT configuration and the traffic is only HTTP or HTTPS and you are decrypting at the F5 and you have an HTTP profile you can enable X-Forwarded-For header field insertion using an iRule, traffic policy, or the easiest way of using an HTTP profile. The X-Forwarded-For header field will be inserted into the HTTP header and a value of the original client IP will be stored as the value of that HTTP header field. You can then configured your pool members to search and record the value of that header for tracking purposes.
Thanks for the reply. I'd rather use a better known solution than mine anyway, considering I have all of about 6ish hours of knowledge with BigIP. I just started spinning up the lab yesterday and I am fully aware there is a whole lot about the system I don't know. So I'll totally set up a snatpool using the same IP as my virtual server and swtich over from auto map to snat!
As for your #2 that totally explains why in a wireshark I'd see a bunch of retransmits and eventually everyone just says "yeah, I'm done" and the connection is dropped. Thanks for the explination!
As for 3# as I said, I have perhaps 6ish hours of BigIP knowledge and I don't understand most of what you said but I'm sure it was helpful to someone else... or perhaps me several months from now.
Thanks again! I'm going to go see if I can figure out how to set up that snatpool.
