Nimbostratus
Nimbostratus * Getting Started on DevCentral
* Community Guidelines
* Community Terms of Use / EULA
* Community Ranking Explained
* Community Resources
* Contact the DevCentral Team
* Update MFA on account.f5.com
* Podcasts
* Social Channels
* Video Streaming
![\"F5](\"https://www.f5.com/content/dam/f5/f5-logo.svg\"){kind=logo}
©2024 F5, Inc. All rights reserved. \n
The application we're trying to load balance is fairly complex and allows multiple types of connections (using different protocols). We have an HTTP (and HTTPS) protocol and a raw TCP protocol. There is a unique identifier we use to determine which application instance a connection is for, and I have iRules for both HTTP and TCP to extract this, which work correctly. It's possible (and very likely) that different connection methods could be used for the same application instance.\n
Here's the problem: the pools seem to be specific to the connection type (port in this case) and each pool has a seperate persistence table. So even though I get the same unique ID the connections may go to different servers. What I really want to do is have a pool that's just the servers themselves (independent of the protocol) and when it routes to a server it just uses the same protocol that it received.\n
Here's an example persistence table I get when trying to connect. You can see that for one of the values (117586) both connection types happened to go to the same server, but for one of the other ones (117587) they went to different ones. Is there any way to set up a pool and iRules such that the persistence table is independent of the protocol being used?\n
The application we're trying to load balance is fairly complex and allows multiple types of connections (using different protocols). We have an HTTP (and HTTPS) protocol and a raw TCP protocol. There is a unique identifier we use to determine which application instance a connection is for, and I have iRules for both HTTP and TCP to extract this, which work correctly. It's possible (and very likely) that different connection methods could be used for the same application instance.\n
Here's the problem: the pools seem to be specific to the connection type (port in this case) and each pool has a seperate persistence table. So even though I get the same unique ID the connections may go to different servers. What I really want to do is have a pool that's just the servers themselves (independent of the protocol) and when it routes to a server it just uses the same protocol that it received.\n
Here's an example persistence table I get when trying to connect. You can see that for one of the values (117586) both connection types happened to go to the same server, but for one of the other ones (117587) they went to different ones. Is there any way to set up a pool and iRules such that the persistence table is independent of the protocol being used?
\nPERSISTENT CONNECTIONS --\n Mode: universal Value: 117587\n Virtual: 10.10.70.171:9080 Node: 10.10.70.39:9080 Age: 98sec\n \n Mode: universal Value: 117587\n Virtual: 10.10.70.171:http Node: 10.10.70.32:http Age: 25sec\n \n Mode: universal Value: 117586\n Virtual: 10.10.70.171:http Node: 10.10.70.32:http Age: 118sec\n \n Mode: universal Value: 117586\n Virtual: 10.10.70.171:9080 Node: 10.10.70.32:9080 Age: 102secThe F5 Certification is excited to announce that all five of the NEW F5 Certified BIG-IP Administrator Certification (F5 CAB) exams are now live and available to schedule via the new Education Services Portal.
","postTime":"2025-04-23T11:16:38.997-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2025-04-25T10:49:39.663-07:00","images":{"__typename":"AssociatedImageConnection","edges":[{"__typename":"AssociatedImageEdge","cursor":"MjUuNHwyLjF8b3wyNXxfTlZffDE","node":{"__ref":"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bS0zNDA5MTEtOEo4VzQw?revision=3\"}"}}],"totalCount":1,"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"tags":{"__typename":"TagConnection","pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":true,"endCursor":"MjUuNHwyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98NQ","hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null},"edges":[{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuNHwyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98MQ","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:101","text":"101","time":"2022-01-24T02:30:16.258-08:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}},{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuNHwyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98Mg","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:201","text":"201","time":"2022-01-24T02:33:36.625-08:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}},{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuNHwyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98Mw","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:administrator","text":"administrator","time":"2024-04-19T00:36:27.334-07:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}},{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuNHwyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98NA","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:announcement","text":"announcement","time":"2021-12-19T07:45:21.000-08:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}},{"__typename":"TagEdge","cursor":"MjUuNHwyLjF8b3w1fF9OVl98NQ","node":{"__typename":"Tag","id":"tag:BIG-IP","text":"BIG-IP","time":"2022-01-24T02:29:45.031-08:00","lastActivityTime":null,"messagesCount":null,"followersCount":null}}]},"timeToRead":3,"introduction":"","metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":994},"placeholder":false,"showMoveIndicator":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"videos":{"__typename":"VideoConnection","edges":[],"totalCount":0,"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}}},"Conversation:conversation:340911":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:340911","solved":false,"topic":{"__ref":"TkbTopicMessage:message:340911"},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2025-04-28T08:13:10.869-07:00","lastPostTime":"2025-04-28T08:13:10.869-07:00","isSubscribed":false},"ModerationData:moderation_data:340911":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:340911","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null},"AssociatedImage:{\"url\":\"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bS0zNDA5MTEtOEo4VzQw?revision=3\"}":{"__typename":"AssociatedImage","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/images/bS0zNDA5MTEtOEo4VzQw?revision=3","title":"clipboard_image-1-1745603317979.png","associationType":"TEASER","width":610,"height":343,"altText":""},"User:user:7":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:7","login":"LiefZimmerman"},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/community/NavbarDropdownToggle-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/community/NavbarDropdownToggle-1749756358382","value":{"ariaLabelClosed":"Press the down arrow to open the menu"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/EscalatedMessageBanner-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/EscalatedMessageBanner-1749756358382","value":{"escalationMessage":"Escalated to Salesforce by {username} on {date}","viewDetails":"View Details","modalTitle":"Case Details","escalatedBy":"Escalated by: ","escalatedOn":"Escalated on: ","caseNumber":"Case Number: ","status":"Status: ","lastUpdateDate":"Last Update: ","automaticEscalation":"automatic escalation","anonymous":"Anonymous"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/users/UserLink-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/users/UserLink-1749756358382","value":{"authorName":"View Profile: {author}","anonymous":"Anonymous"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/users/UserRank-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/users/UserRank-1749756358382","value":{"rankName":"{rankName}","userRank":"Author rank {rankName}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageTime-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageTime-1749756358382","value":{"postTime":"Published: {time}","lastPublishTime":"Last Update: {time}","conversation.lastPostingActivityTime":"Last posting activity time: {time}","conversation.lastPostTime":"Last post time: {time}","moderationData.rejectTime":"Rejected time: {time}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageSolvedBadge-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageSolvedBadge-1749756358382","value":{"solved":"Solved"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageSubject-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageSubject-1749756358382","value":{"noSubject":"(no subject)"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageBody-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageBody-1749756358382","value":{"showMessageBody":"Show More","mentionsErrorTitle":"{mentionsType, select, board {Board} user {User} message {Message} other {}} No Longer Available","mentionsErrorMessage":"The {mentionsType} you are trying to view has been removed from the community.","videoProcessing":"Video is being processed. Please try again in a few minutes.","bannerTitle":"Video provider requires cookies to play the video. Accept to continue or {url} it directly on the provider's site.","buttonTitle":"Accept","urlText":"watch"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageCustomFields-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageCustomFields-1749756358382","value":{"CustomField.default.label":"Value of {name}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageReplyButton-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageReplyButton-1749756358382","value":{"repliesCount":"{count}","title":"Reply","title@board:BLOG@message:root":"Comment","title@board:TKB@message:root":"Comment","title@board:IDEA@message:root":"Comment","title@board:OCCASION@message:root":"Comment"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewCard-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewCard-1749756358382","value":{"gotoParent":"Go to parent {name}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewInline-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/MessageView/MessageViewInline-1749756358382","value":{"bylineAuthor":"{bylineAuthor}","bylineBoard":"{bylineBoard}","anonymous":"Anonymous","place":"Place {bylineBoard}","gotoParent":"Go to parent {name}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/common/Pager/PagerLoadMore-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/common/Pager/PagerLoadMore-1749756358382","value":{"loadMore":"Show More"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/customComponent/CustomComponent-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/customComponent/CustomComponent-1749756358382","value":{"errorMessage":"Error rendering component id: {customComponentId}","bannerTitle":"Video provider requires cookies to play the video. Accept to continue or {url} it directly on the provider's site.","buttonTitle":"Accept","urlText":"watch"},"localOverride":false},"ModerationData:moderation_data:87826":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:87826","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null,"isReportedAbuse":false,"rejectUser":null,"rejectTime":null,"rejectActorType":null},"Revision:revision:87826_1":{"__typename":"Revision","id":"revision:87826_1","lastEditTime":"2006-06-29T12:11:15.000-07:00"},"QueryVariables:ReplyList:message:208055:2":{"__typename":"QueryVariables","id":"ReplyList:message:208055:2","value":{"id":"message:208055","first":10,"sorts":{"postTime":{"direction":"ASC"}},"repliesFirst":3,"repliesFirstDepthThree":1,"repliesSorts":{"postTime":{"direction":"ASC"}},"useAvatar":true,"useAuthorLogin":true,"useAuthorRank":true,"useBody":true,"useKudosCount":true,"useTimeToRead":false,"useMedia":false,"useReadOnlyIcon":false,"useRepliesCount":true,"useSearchSnippet":false,"useAcceptedSolutionButton":true,"useSolvedBadge":false,"useAttachments":false,"attachmentsFirst":5,"useTags":false,"useNodeAncestors":false,"useUserHoverCard":false,"useNodeHoverCard":false,"useModerationStatus":true,"usePreviewSubjectModal":false,"useMessageStatus":true}},"ROOT_MUTATION":{"__typename":"Mutation"},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/users/UserAvatar-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/users/UserAvatar-1749756358382","value":{"altText":"{login}'s avatar","altTextGeneric":"User's avatar"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/ranks/UserRankLabel-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/ranks/UserRankLabel-1749756358382","value":{"altTitle":"Icon for {rankName} rank"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/tags/TagView/TagViewChip-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/tags/TagView/TagViewChip-1749756358382","value":{"tagLabelName":"Tag name {tagName}"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/AcceptedSolutionButton-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/AcceptedSolutionButton-1749756358382","value":{"accept":"Mark as Solution","accepted":"Marked as Solution","errorHeader":"Error!","errorAdd":"There was an error marking as solution.","errorRemove":"There was an error unmarking as solution.","solved":"Solved","topicAlreadySolvedErrorTitle":"Solution Already Exists","topicAlreadySolvedErrorDesc":"Refresh the browser to view the existing solution"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-components/messages/ThreadedReplyList-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-components/messages/ThreadedReplyList-1749756358382","value":{"title":"{count, plural, one{# Reply} other{# Replies}}","title@board:BLOG":"{count, plural, one{# Comment} other{# Comments}}","title@board:TKB":"{count, plural, one{# Comment} other{# Comments}}","title@board:IDEA":"{count, plural, one{# Comment} other{# Comments}}","title@board:OCCASION":"{count, plural, one{# Comment} other{# Comments}}","noRepliesTitle":"No Replies","noRepliesTitle@board:BLOG":"No Comments","noRepliesTitle@board:TKB":"No Comments","noRepliesTitle@board:IDEA":"No Comments","noRepliesTitle@board:OCCASION":"No Comments","noRepliesDescription":"Be the first to reply","noRepliesDescription@board:BLOG":"Be the first to comment","noRepliesDescription@board:TKB":"Be the first to comment","noRepliesDescription@board:IDEA":"Be the first to comment","noRepliesDescription@board:OCCASION":"Be the first to comment","messageReadOnlyAlert:BLOG":"Comments have been turned off for this post","messageReadOnlyAlert:TKB":"Comments have been turned off for this article","messageReadOnlyAlert:IDEA":"Comments have been turned off for this idea","messageReadOnlyAlert:FORUM":"Replies have been turned off for this discussion","messageReadOnlyAlert:OCCASION":"Comments have been turned off for this event"},"localOverride":false},"CachedAsset:text:en_US-shared/client/components/nodes/NodeIcon-1749756358382":{"__typename":"CachedAsset","id":"text:en_US-shared/client/components/nodes/NodeIcon-1749756358382","value":{"contentType":"Content Type {style, select, FORUM {Forum} BLOG {Blog} TKB {Knowledge Base} IDEA {Ideas} OCCASION {Events} other {}} icon"},"localOverride":false},"User:user:150494":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:150494","entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:150494","deleted":false,"uid":150494,"login":"ebrc","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2011-11-03T01:00:00.000-07:00"},"email":"","avatar":{"__typename":"UserAvatar","url":"https://community.f5.com/t5/s/zihoc95639/m_assets/avatars/default/avatar-10.svg?time=0"},"rank":{"__ref":"Rank:rank:41"}},"ForumTopicMessage:message:208052":{"__typename":"ForumTopicMessage","uid":208052,"id":"message:208052","entityType":"FORUM_TOPIC","eventPath":"category:Forums/community:zihoc95639board:TechnicalForum/message:208052","revisionNum":1,"author":{"__ref":"User:user:150494"},"readOnly":false,"repliesCount":6,"subject":"iRule to modify response code for ASM blocking page"},"User:user:149730":{"__typename":"User","id":"user:149730","entityType":"USER","eventPath":"community:zihoc95639/user:149730","deleted":false,"uid":149730,"login":"Enes_Afsin_Al","biography":null,"registrationData":{"__typename":"RegistrationData","status":null,"registrationTime":"2019-05-16T05:58:51.000-07:00"}},"ForumReplyMessage:message:208055":{"__typename":"ForumReplyMessage","uid":208055,"id":"message:208055","entityType":"FORUM_REPLY","eventPath":"category:Forums/community:zihoc95639board:TechnicalForum/message:208052/message:208055","revisionNum":2,"author":{"__ref":"User:user:149730"},"readOnly":false,"repliesCount":1,"parent":{"__ref":"ForumTopicMessage:message:208052"},"replies":{"__typename":"MessageConnection","edges":[{"__typename":"MessageEdge","cursor":"MjUuNHwyLjF8aXwxMHwzOToxfGludCwyMDgwNTYsMjA4MDU2","node":{"__ref":"ForumReplyMessage:message:208056"}}],"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}},"customFields":[],"attachments":{"__typename":"AttachmentConnection","edges":[],"pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null}}},"Conversation:conversation:208052":{"__typename":"Conversation","id":"conversation:208052","solved":false,"topic":{"__ref":"ForumTopicMessage:message:208052"},"lastPostingActivityTime":"2019-09-19T04:36:32.000-07:00","lastPostTime":"2019-09-19T04:36:32.000-07:00","unreadReplyCount":6,"isSubscribed":false},"ModerationData:moderation_data:208056":{"__typename":"ModerationData","id":"moderation_data:208056","status":"APPROVED","rejectReason":null,"isReportedAbuse":false,"rejectUser":null,"rejectTime":null,"rejectActorType":null},"ForumReplyMessage:message:208056":{"__typename":"ForumReplyMessage","author":{"__ref":"User:user:150494"},"id":"message:208056","entityType":"FORUM_REPLY","eventPath":"category:Forums/community:zihoc95639board:TechnicalForum/message:208052/message:208056","revisionNum":1,"uid":208056,"depth":2,"hasGivenKudo":false,"subscribed":false,"board":{"__ref":"Forum:board:TechnicalForum"},"parent":{"__ref":"ForumReplyMessage:message:208055"},"conversation":{"__ref":"Conversation:conversation:208052"},"subject":"Re: iRule to modify response code for ASM blocking page","moderationData":{"__ref":"ModerationData:moderation_data:208056"},"body":"Thank you eaa!
I will try and give feedback then.
There is no way to just keep the ASM blocking page from ASM policy (that we already replaced by the customer's one) and just replace the error code?
I think your way will work, but we will have to maintain the same blocking page in 2 different places (ASM + ifile)
","body@stripHtml({\"removeProcessingText\":false,\"removeSpoilerMarkup\":false,\"removeTocMarkup\":false,\"truncateLength\":200})@stringLength":"208","kudosSumWeight":0,"repliesCount":0,"postTime":"2019-09-05T05:42:50.000-07:00","lastPublishTime":"2019-09-05T05:42:50.000-07:00","metrics":{"__typename":"MessageMetrics","views":812},"visibilityScope":"PUBLIC","placeholder":false,"showMoveIndicator":false,"originalMessageForPlaceholder":null,"isEscalated":null,"solution":false,"replies":{"__typename":"MessageConnection","pageInfo":{"__typename":"PageInfo","hasNextPage":false,"endCursor":null,"hasPreviousPage":false,"startCursor":null},"edges":[]}},"QueryVariables:ReplyList:message:87826:1":{"__typename":"QueryVariables","id":"ReplyList:message:87826:1","value":{"id":"message:87826","first":10,"sorts":{"postTime":{"direction":"ASC"}},"repliesFirst":3,"repliesFirstDepthThree":1,"repliesSorts":{"postTime":{"direction":"ASC"}},"useAvatar":true,"useAuthorLogin":true,"useAuthorRank":true,"useBody":true,"useKudosCount":true,"useTimeToRead":false,"useMedia":false,"useReadOnlyIcon":false,"useRepliesCount":true,"useSearchSnippet":false,"useAcceptedSolutionButton":true,"useSolvedBadge":false,"useAttachments":false,"attachmentsFirst":5,"useTags":false,"useNodeAncestors":false,"useUserHoverCard":false,"useNodeHoverCard":false,"useModerationStatus":true,"usePreviewSubjectModal":false,"useMessageStatus":true}}}}},"page":"/forums/ForumMessagePage/ForumMessagePage","query":{"boardId":"technicalforum","messageSubject":"share-persistence-values-for-multiple-protocols","messageId":"87824","replyId":"87826"},"buildId":"3XH0qYWYCnEYycuN5W4S8","runtimeConfig":{"buildInformationVisible":false,"logLevelApp":"info","logLevelMetrics":"info","surveysEnabled":true,"openTelemetry":{"clientEnabled":false,"configName":"f5","serviceVersion":"25.4.0","universe":"prod","collector":"http://localhost:4318","logLevel":"error","routeChangeAllowedTime":"5000","headers":"","enableDiagnostic":"false","maxAttributeValueLength":"4095"},"apolloDevToolsEnabled":false,"quiltLazyLoadThreshold":"3"},"isFallback":false,"isExperimentalCompile":false,"dynamicIds":["components_seo_QAPageSchema","components_customComponent_CustomComponent","components_community_Navbar_NavbarWidget","components_community_Breadcrumb_BreadcrumbWidget","components_messages_TopicWithThreadedReplyListWidget","components_featured_content_FeaturedContentWidget","components_messages_MessageListForNodeByRecentActivityWidget","components_messages_RelatedContentWidget","components_messages_MessageView_MessageViewStandard","components_customComponent_CustomComponentContent_TemplateContent","components_messages_EscalatedMessageBanner","shared_client_components_common_List_GridList","components_messages_MessageView","components_messages_MessageView_MessageViewCard","shared_client_components_common_List_UnstyledList","components_messages_MessageView_MessageViewInline","shared_client_components_common_Pager_PagerLoadMore","components_customComponent_CustomComponentContent_HtmlContent","shared_client_components_common_List_UnwrappedList","components_tags_TagView","components_tags_TagView_TagViewChip","components_customComponent_CustomComponentContent_CustomComponentScripts"],"appGip":true,"scriptLoader":[]}