Hi Guys, thanks for the responses. What I did yesterday to resolve the problem is examined the IIS configs on my two Exchange servers, and noticed that the root of the Default Web Site was requiring SSL. I did not think that was correct, so I unchecked it and ran IISRESET. That seemed to resolve the issue. It seems odd that both Exchange servers were configured this way, yet only one was getting a false positive from the monitor.
Ryan, when I go to System > Support, the only option I have is "Download Snapshot File". Is that what you are referring to?
Adam